Finished the 3rd volume. It was OK. I did not regret reading it. Not a waste of time. But a bit unsatisfying. Not even close to being my favorite Donaldson. It had a bit of "paint by numbers" feel. A hint of fan fiction. Punches were telegraphed well in advance. One of the many things I lo...

I assume the Xian imagery is intentional, negative, and a comment on current events in the states. Steve is pulling no punches here.

Avatar wrote: ↑

Russ Hatton wrote: ↑ Just started volume 3. This is not my favorite Donaldson.

Welcome @Russ Hatton.

So, what is your favourite Donaldson?

--A

My favorite is the Gap Cycle. Astonishing scifi that does not get the attention it deserves. 1st Covenant series is a close 2nd.

Estie is too much of a Mary Sue

Just started volume 3. This is not my favorite Donaldson.