The SoulBiter is my namesake!!! Great work on this Wayfriend and the comments that followed were enlightening. I had not thought of the SoulBiter in this way. Although this was an opponent with no physical teeth it obviously was able to bite the soul. I could not imagine seeing SeaDreamer and have h...

OH yah.. sign me up as well !

When I think of the scar in this chapter I dont think Masters scar as the scar that Seadreamer carried but more the scar on Honniscraves soul. The scar of guilt for his part in what happened to his brother Seadreamer. Can you imagine how it must have hurt Covenant to refuse Honniscrave? His Love of ...

I think this chapter is easily the one most filled with foreboding in the whole book You hooked me with that first sentence. I just had to read the rest and the rest was indeed a great dissection of a chapter. I have nothing to add to that. Super job!!! I get my first try at a dissection in WGW. I ...

I cant say that I have ever given up on a book before I finished it. The only series I ever gave up on has been Robert Jordans Wheel of Time. I got through the first 6 books and then decided the story was going no where. He is on what? Book 11 now? Lord of the Rings is perhaps the only set of books ...

WOW!! Durris that was incredible. Not just the chapter (although that was incredible in itself) but your interpretation of it. Im still not sure how you were able to compress this chapter the way you did. I was thinking as I read this that Covenant had to be conscious of the fact that he was more th...

Matrixman wrote: The "proposed punishment was excessive"? Durris, that's what I call an understatement. But was it? Would you have thought it excessive if she had succeeded? She attempted Ceers life. The only difference between attempted murder and murder is the fact that Cail stopped the...

Im new here but I would be willing to dissect a chapter. Just tell me which one and I will be glad to do it. If I dont get any of the One Tree, Im hopeful of doing some of WGW.

Wow, I showed up on page 99 and here we are on 104 already.
Thanks to everyone for the warm welcome!

As Amok would say:
"Courtesy is like a drink at a mountain stream. I am honored already."

It should be done as an animated film, with Sean Connery as the voice of Mhoram, and James Earl Jones as Foul. Totally agree with this. Remember that Foul is only really seen as a non-corporeal presence with glaring red eyes. (Except there at the end of the Power that Preserves) Every time I read L...

I love this chapter and you have done an outstanding job dissecting this one!!! We withdraw our accusation against the Chosen. She has adjudged us rightly. [Huh? When did she judge them at all? Or does Brinn mean when she said You don't have the right; when they were judging her?] Mayhap she is in s...

Trying to point to any one thing that actually hooked me is very difficult. It was the fact that Covenant was becoming the anti-hero which I had never seen an author do. Then the way the people of the Land worked with the Land to accomplish such feats. Giants, Haruchai, the Bloodguard who swore a vo...

Why, do you think, were the Earthpower incarnate Elohim unable to see what Mhoram, a puny mortal, saw - that TC himself was the white gold? I think they did see it. When Chant first appeared he looked at Linden and said "You are the sun sage" and then looked over at Covenant and said &quo...

I always thought that they (Brinn and Cail) had already decided to come back to the Merewives. Not because of their unworth but because the experience somehow changed them. The change I think was perhaps a closer understanding of themselves. Ak-Haru Kenaustin Ardenol told Covenant Cail will accept m...

I hate it when I do that.. I posted when I wasnt logged in and became "guest"

Woops!

SoulBiter

In fact, there are some grounds to doubt whether anyone who wishes to appear to be a leader can actually be one. This statement I totally agree with. Prothall though had the doom of the land on his head... knowing that his decisions would mean not just life or death for the Lords but for the Land. ...

Im a Republican but I wont be voting for Bush. After the election I had some hope that things would turn out well especially with the Republicans controlling both houses of congress and a Republican president. But this has been a disappointing 4 years.... What happened to fiscal conservatism? Gone o...

I always thought that Prothall was such a great leader.. its no wonder that he was the High Lord of the council in the first of the series. The trial and the doom of this time are on my head. I am High Lord Prothall, and by consent of the council my will prevails. Let none fear to follow me, or blam...

How long will these be on sale? Im thinking Ive gotta have one.. just not in the next couple of weeks.

SoulBiter

True enough... and even the Haruchai didnt have the same vision either until they took the vows of the bloodguard. Good points.. thanks. Sometimes it takes someone elses eyes to get a clearer understanding.