wayfriend wrote:Hang on. NO ONE in the Land can defeat Foul. That's the whole premise of the story.
Fault Kevin for other things. But not for being unable to defeat the Despiser. So there's no statement about the adequacy of lore here. Or of wisdom. Kevin damned himself by his choices, not by his eficacy.
Mhoram would have been defeated as well. But he would have lost with his integrity in tact.
I agree that no one in the Land can defeat Foul, but Kevin was the apotheosis of that idea. Kevin is Casey at the bat. He's the biggest, most powerful, most lore-wise Lord ever. He probably commanded the greatest army of good the Land had ever seen. He's the pinnacle of what power a human High Lord can wield. That's why it's so crushing when we/he realized
it wasn't enough.
No other High Lord (Mhoram, Elena, etc) can be more powerful than Kevin, because that would abrogate or somehow diminish the whole point of Kevin. You can't have another batter come up after Casey who is even better.