Syl wrote:Elvis, Johnny Cash, Sinatra, too. They're men's men. *shrug* The Beatles were just really good musicians.
my mate likes to say "full grown men" about musicians like Cash, Sinatra, (i don't know that he would include Elvis) Jimmy Page, Hendrix, Leslie West, ZZ Top, Mick and Keith, etc. (yes, mostly guitar gods). music played by full grown men.
the Beatles didn't ever really fit that mold, so to speak, with the exception of John Lennon, (see disclaimer below

but i always thought the argument was Beatles vs Stones? Elvis never entered into it for me. he was kinda out there on his own. no one really to compare him to for me.