Harbinger wrote:Why not keep the thred alive by not having a single host? Anyone could submit a topic as long as there wasn't a current game and they had the loot to pay the prize. Peers would vote as usual, but the topic creator would not be able to comopete. In this way, the burden of creativity would not be on one person all the time, you wouldn't have to wait for one person to save up 500 WGDs, the person who created the topic wouldn't have an unfair advantage and could still play another one soon, the game would be in more constant motion, and everyone could have a chance to submit a topic.
Actually, I think the idea of the single host is a good idea who can compile the ideas together, and keep it on track and organized as opposed to higglety pigglety postings that will quickly sputter out, as things like this do. I think the reason this thread was successful was because there was some amount of order, and was done week after week (until it ended up to whenever wayfriend had another $500), with a clear start and finish (which got pushed back occasionally). And like I said when I originally thought to resurrect this thread, it wouldn't be just one topic creator - it would be a free for all on submitting ideas, but would be boiled down to one topic per week. It kept the time commitment down for those competing, which encouraged more competition, and got some excitement up for it. If there are multiple "Win My Money" threads, the idea will go stale quickly.
But, whatever. It looks like it has already started the way you suggested anyway. My original idea was to get rid of some of my WGD and infuse the creativity that this thread inspired. Pay for entertainment, if you will. If it happens, then good. But in my opinion, if it isn't kept to one contest a week, it will quickly die on the vine.