Posted: Sat Jan 27, 2007 10:11 pm
She's no squib.variol son wrote:The quote apparentl says "not Petunia".
As for Narcissa, I'm pretty sure she aparates to Snape's home so she can't be a squib.
Official Discussion Forum for the works of Stephen R. Donaldson
https://kevinswatch.com/phpBB3/
She's no squib.variol son wrote:The quote apparentl says "not Petunia".
As for Narcissa, I'm pretty sure she aparates to Snape's home so she can't be a squib.
Yeah I know... though in fairness, my suggestion doesn't require that PETUNIA wind up with magic abilities...only that she defends her own "dudders" or whatever she call him. A Mother's love and all of that. Jes thinkin' out loud.Cameraman Jenn wrote:Guns, darling, JKR has officially stated that Petunia is NOT going to be the one to perform magic late in life. Sorry.
That is precisely why I ruled out Dudley as the late bloomer.You'd thinbk that if Dudley had any game, it'd come out when he was set upon by Dementors
Doesn't she apparate to the village where Snape lives?I honestly didn't seriously consider the fact that Narcissa could be a Squib, I just didn't think we had seen her actually performing magic, and thought it would be hillarious to see her revealed as a Squib.
sindatur wrote:The rumors are not the date of the movie release though, the rumors are 07-07-07 (7 is an important number throughout the series) or 07-31-07 (JKR and Harry and Neville's birthday).
The last several books (I don't recall when this started) have all been released on a Friday. While those rumors certainly seem to carry some weight, it would seem odd to change an established pattern.
Yes, I believe there is some mention of her apparating at some point (Either a reference that she could apparate to Durmstrang, if Draco attended there, or maybe apparating to Snape's) which I had forgotten.Cameraman Jenn wrote:Guns wrote:That is precisely why I ruled out Dudley as the late bloomer.You'd thinbk that if Dudley had any game, it'd come out when he was set upon by Dementors
Sin wrote:Doesn't she apparate to the village where Snape lives?I honestly didn't seriously consider the fact that Narcissa could be a Squib, I just didn't think we had seen her actually performing magic, and thought it would be hillarious to see her revealed as a Squib.
I had always believed it unlikely that they would be released so close together, but, I have been convinced otherwise recently. Previously, I always figured at least a 4 month gap between a new movie release, and a new book release. As long as we hear by end of February, it would still fall in line with previous books release dates compared to our knowledge of status. If Feb comes and goes, with no announcement, then history tells us it won't be ready by July.Cameraman Jenn wrote:Narcissa apparates in HBP.
I am doubting a July 7 release simply because the movie release is the following weekend. July 31st seems more reasonable if it's even going to be released in July. I just checked her website and there haven't been any new updates since she posted that she was struggling with writing some scenes so it's not even finished yet. When she does finish it, things like editing and rewrites still have to be done and final publishing acceptance has to occur. Then it has to go to the printers, get typeset etc. I think a July release might be pushing it.
Certainly you have a point, if we knew what stage she was in, however, we never know what stage she is in, except "not finished" and "ready to go to the printing house". She has never told us things like "first go 'round with editing" or "My editor, just kicked it back for a final revision" or anything of that nature. To the best of my recollection, it's always "not finished", until they announce 4-5 months away is the "street date" and the Publishing details. Does anyone recollect anything different?Cameraman Jenn wrote:Well, look at it this way, we already know that Fatal Revenant has an official release date of October of this year. We also know that SRD is finished with the third draft and it's been submitted to the publishers. JKR isn't even finished with the first draft yet. I have alot of trouble believing that she's gonna finish the book, finish the rewrites and submit it to the publishers have it accepted etc. in time for a July release.
Pessimism thy name in "CammJenn"Cameraman Jenn wrote:Well, look at it this way, we already know that Fatal Revenant has an official release date of October of this year. We also know that SRD is finished with the third draft and it's been submitted to the publishers. JKR isn't even finished with the first draft yet. I have alot of trouble believing that she's gonna finish the book, finish the rewrites and submit it to the publishers have it accepted etc. in time for a July release.