Posted: Sun May 27, 2007 1:33 am
Seriously, AK. Your arguments are ridiculous. I'll be ignoring you from now on.
Official Discussion Forum for the works of Stephen R. Donaldson
https://kevinswatch.com/phpBB3/
The same type of diplomacy you used with Quee? One that is ended but a few days afterwards with miltary action, and the death of a God?Nor Yekith wrote:And if I stated I am willing to negotiate? Surely, you are not be so aggressive that you would declare war on another god who is willing to use diplomatic means to achieve harmony?
I do agree that such a thing would be a bad misscarriage of Justice. But my stance has never been that the Gods are not to expand to different areas of the world, for do we not all have believers in lands that are not our own?Nor Yekith wrote: What of AK? You argue Malice and Mutation is a bad mixture, what about Chaos and Destruction? The god of undead? The god of demons? I could go on. If you really want to argue I'm a threat because of who I am, please at least carry your principles further. Even the god of justice can see this is an abuse.
Well, you should have stated that I was not to expand. No one stated as such, and so I am being punished for a law you've only just decided to invent. Second, your arguments regarding my ultimate motives are suspect. I have always stated I have the intent to improve the world, but intent and action are two entirely different things. Please read the documents detailing previous discussions on this issue; I made it clear I wanted to work with other gods to this goal.Lord Adomorn wrote:No, I've stated multiple times why I am fighting against you Nor. It is that you are actively trying to take the world. It is not yours, OR mine to take.
No, you're not willing to negotiate. I said I am, yet you have brought nothing to the table other than threats. Here I am, willing to negotiate. Now negotiate.Lord Adomorn wrote:I would be willing to negotiate, but I have a hard time believing that you will give up spreading your paradise to all corners of Eiran. A very hard time.
I have never said that you were not to expand, Nor. Did you not take a large portion of Khenstorn? Did I say anything then? I did not, because it did not come out of nowhere. It was expected and anticipated, and honestly, would you have allowed anyone else to claim those lands? Of course not, so no one made any other claims.Nor Yekith wrote:Well, you should have stated that I was not to expand. No one stated as such, and so I am being punished for a law you've only just decided to invent. Second, your arguments regarding my ultimate motives are suspect. I have always stated I have the intent to improve the world, but intent and action are two entirely different things. Please read the documents detailing previous discussions on this issue; I made it clear I wanted to work with other gods to this goal.
I do not know what your a willing to agree to. Give some baseline, and we'll go from there.Nor Yekith wrote: No, you're not willing to negotiate. I said I am, yet you have brought nothing to the table other than threats. Here I am, willing to negotiate. Now negotiate.
I'm sorry, but I took no more than any other god did of another continent.Lord Adomorn wrote:I have never said that you were not to expand, Nor. Did you not take a large portion of Khenstorn?
The same way no one else made claims to the section I transformed.Lord Adomorn wrote:Did I say anything then? I did not, because it did not come out of nowhere. It was expected and anticipated, and honestly, would you have allowed anyone else to claim those lands? Of course not, so no one made any other claims.
Again, I will work with other gods to bring this about. Therefore, Yekithii is the end of the expansion.Lord Adomorn wrote:But in ONE seaon, you took over a third of a continent. How are we supposed to take such a massive and sudden expansion, except as the first steps of your many-times preached "spreading of paradise"? This paradise will destory the world.
Allow me Yekithii, that is, with new borders adjusted.Lord Adomorn wrote:I do not know what your a willing to agree to. Give some baseline, and we'll go from there.
*Laughs* Like yourself? Like Maeror, Undine . . . ?Lord Adomorn wrote:I just wanted to make clear with that last statment that you dont have a very good track record of past kept peace agreements to give credence to your sudden exclamation of "PEACE!"
Exactally the point I was making. "No more than any other God."Nor Yekith wrote: I'm sorry, but I took no more than any other god did of another continent.
But then, there was a season of calm before you moved in. We looked down for a moment and when we look back a third of Imerill is mutated and no one could go there, even if we wanted to.Nor Yekith wrote: The same way no one else made claims to the section I transformed.
So this one statement is going to wipe aways the years of telling us all that you are the only one capable to bring the world to paradise? Even if this is the first step towards peace, it will be a long while yet before anyone can take this seriously.Nor Yekith wrote: Again, I will work with other gods to bring this about. Therefore, Yekithii is the end of the expansion.
What do you mean with the new borders? Back or forward?Nor Yekith wrote:Allow me Yekithii, that is, with new borders adjusted.
Nor Yekith wrote: *Laughs* Like yourself? Like Maeror, Undine . . . ?
Undine spoke of your dumping of Mutagens into the seas long ago. Perhaps I misunderstood. But I would be interested to know how you prevent them from spreading throughout the seas of Eiran. You are not the God of Water, after all. Are your Mutagens programmed to latch onto the coastline immediately when they leave the Star of Yekith's influence, so that they do not enter the realms of other deities?Nor Yekith wrote:Into the coastline surrounding Nor Pupae. For defense.Bhakti wrote:What could you possibly promise? You have been pumping Mutagens into the waters forever.
Am I misinterpreting this? It doesn't sound like this wave of Malice is contained to your coastal areas. It sounds like it might be an act of some sort against the seas in general.Allfather wrote:And then Nor Yekith's malice poured from Nor Pupae into the seas,
You asked for negotiations. If I am one of the ones you would negotiate with, you are hearing my concerns. Others can speak for themselves, but none of my effects have ever spread into the world. I have never even attempted to put something into motion that might spread to the world, and nobody has ever told me of any instances where it happened anyway.Nor Yekith wrote:As opposed to other gods' effects spreading into the world . . .Bhakti wrote:The go everywhere, Mutating whatever they touch.
Well, yes. You are negotiating for peace. You want all to agree to NOT attack you, and in return, you will not Mutate our lands or followers. But your Mutagens conveniently find ways out of Nor Pupae, and Mutate us anyway. All the while, you say, "It wasn't on purpose. You can't attack me, because I'm not trying to Mutate you." Will you ensure that this kind of thing can't happen? Or will you take the Oath to make the situation right each time it does? I have heard many instances of one deity or his/her followers damaging another's lands or followers, and restitution is often made.Nor Yekith wrote:Oh, so now I am responsible for everyone? Basically, this is not my fault. Further, I have made it clear I am conducting an inquisition of my lands, so that anyone not of my cult is imprisoned or forced out of my lands. So even though I try to catch them all, because I fail now and then, it's really all my fault.Bhakti wrote:Adventurers snuck into Nor Pupae while you were away, and then came to Shakari. They carried Mutagens with them, and my people suffered "monstrous births" as a result.
You have set things up so that even you cannot prevent the world's Mutation. Eventually, your Mutagens will get out, and spread everywhere. And, since you readily admit that you intend to transform all of Eiran, this is all to your liking anyway. Since you have promised my destruction more than once, I don't see why I should bother asking others to not destroy you.Nor Yekith wrote:So basically, I've no choice; I have to destroyed.Bhakti wrote:Even if you took the Oath to not intentionally act against other deities, their followers, or their lands, there is no way to prevent your vision of Eiran. You have set it up too well for your success. It will happen. You have nothing to lose by promising non-aggression.
AK is another matter. When he asks the Pantheon to negotiate, we'll discuss it.Nor Yekith wrote:Give me a break, Bhakti. What of AK? You argue Malice and Mutation is a bad mixture, what about Chaos and Destruction? The god of undead? The god of demons? I could go on. If you really want to argue I'm a threat because of who I am, please at least carry your principles further. Even the god of justice can see this is an abuse.
Sister, thank you for looking out for my neighbor's and my interests. I have been talking with L-rd Adomorn privately, and he and I are still in heated debate. I appreciate another negotiator, one perhaps not so closely attuned to 'protecting' all of Eiran, in entering these talks as well.Norn wrote:Asking Nor Yekith to begin negotiations is foolish, since he is nto the one about to go to war. Those who oppose him must say what they desire of him that would prevent them from marching against his lands.
I will therefore begin, though I am neutral in this matter.
Nor Yekith, we desire that this expansion into Yekithii would be the last as you have said, and that you would work together with Astavyastataa Kadna and O-gon-cho to establish clear borders.
Agreed.Norn wrote:Nor Yekith, we desire that this expansion into Yekithii would be the last as you have said, and that you would work together with Astavyastataa Kadna and O-gon-cho to establish clear borders.
I am sorry, but I cannot allow this. I bathe my lands in mutative energies almost weekly - which I have the right to do. If I relax my attitude to foreigners, must I also stop the perfectiong of my land? Perhaps some gods need to rein in their wandering followers.Norn wrote:We desire that you accept that there are times when the followers of other deitys will pass through your lands attending to matters that have nothing to do with you, and that you relax your xenophobic restrictions to allow for such accidental instances.
Interesting. This is the first I have heard about this.Norn wrote:We desire that you relax your interdict upon Khenstorn that those lands that were once claimed by Chisi La'Roo would remain free and would not automatically revert to either yourself or Melirelle because the worshippers of all other deitys cannot stand to reside there.
Lord Adomorn wrote:What do you mean with the new borders? Back or forward?Nor Yekith wrote:Allow me Yekithii, that is, with new borders adjusted.
We certainly cannot ask you to cease mutating within the boundaries of both Nor Pupae and Yekithii, and indeed any follower of another deity who wanders into your lands does so at the risk that he or she may indeed be changed by those mutating energies you have mentioned. Perhaps if you had explained this reason behind your continued demands that your borders remain inviolate then we would have understood sooner and this would not have been an issue.Nor Yekith wrote:I am sorry, but I cannot allow this. I bathe my lands in mutative energies almost weekly - which I have the right to do. If I relax my attitude to foreigners, must I also stop the perfectiong of my land? Perhaps some gods need to rein in their wandering followers.Norn wrote:We desire that you accept that there are times when the followers of other deitys will pass through your lands attending to matters that have nothing to do with you, and that you relax your xenophobic restrictions to allow for such accidental instances.
The All-Father has informed us all this season that "a strange unease grips any mortal who sets foot on Khenstorn, unless he worships one of the Khenstorn Gods. This unease seems to grow with each passing hour, making it impossible to stay on Khenstorn for a long period of time." This may of course be Melirelle's doing, but I am surprised you knew nothing of it.Nor Yekith wrote:Interesting. This is the first I have heard about this.Norn wrote:We desire that you relax your interdict upon Khenstorn that those lands that were once claimed by Chisi La'Roo would remain free and would not automatically revert to either yourself or Melirelle because the worshippers of all other deitys cannot stand to reside there.
The King has always maintained an exclusionary stance. ((OOC: *shrug* roleplaying for you there*))Norn wrote:We certainly cannot ask you to cease mutating within the boundaries of both Nor Pupae and Yekithii, and indeed any follower of another deity who wanders into your lands does so at the risk that he or she may indeed be changed by those mutating energies you have mentioned. Perhaps if you had explained this reason behind your continued demands that your borders remain inviolate then we would have understood sooner and this would not have been an issue.
Again, this is the first I have heard about it. What if it's someone else?Norn wrote:The All-Father has informed us all this season that "a strange unease grips any mortal who sets foot on Khenstorn, unless he worships one of the Khenstorn Gods. This unease seems to grow with each passing hour, making it impossible to stay on Khenstorn for a long period of time." This may of course be Melirelle's doing, but I am surprised you knew nothing of it.
((OOC: A wise suggestion? I'm not playing this game to have my powers 'tied behind my back'. All it takes is some thinking to realise how this rule can be abused by others - not myself. Second, I will ONLY agree to this if every other god agrees to the rule, and that would lead to the end of the game.))Norn wrote:Finally, I believe that Astavyastataa Kadna has put forth a wise suggestion. Would you consent to sealing the powers of malice and mutation within your borders to prevent any inadvertent spread?
The King has maintained an exclusionary stance yet both he and you have appeared to care little when your own followers have been discovered in places where they did not belong. This mistrust has festered. Now that we know why you desire your lands to remain inviolate we can better instruct our own followers to insure that this is the case.Nor Yekith wrote:The King has always maintained an exclusionary stance.Norn wrote:We certainly cannot ask you to cease mutating within the boundaries of both Nor Pupae and Yekithii, and indeed any follower of another deity who wanders into your lands does so at the risk that he or she may indeed be changed by those mutating energies you have mentioned. Perhaps if you had explained this reason behind your continued demands that your borders remain inviolate then we would have understood sooner and this would not have been an issue.
In which case you need not concern yourself with it and the request becomes irrelevent. I made the request only because it concerned Khenstorn and you are the continent's pre-eminent deity. You know nothing of the this "strange unease", so those who are concerned by it will investigate elsewhere.Nor Yekith wrote:Again, this is the first I have heard about it. What if it's someone else?Norn wrote:The All-Father has informed us all this season that "a strange unease grips any mortal who sets foot on Khenstorn, unless he worships one of the Khenstorn Gods. This unease seems to grow with each passing hour, making it impossible to stay on Khenstorn for a long period of time." This may of course be Melirelle's doing, but I am surprised you knew nothing of it.
I understand your position, and I do not wish to so limit any deity. However, how else may we insure that the rest of Eiran remains unmutated? You have promised that you will not actively spread your mutagens beyond the borders of Nor Pupae and Yekithii, yet it has been noted that the mutagens still find ways of spreading throughout our world.Nor Yekith wrote:((OOC: A wise suggestion? I'm not playing this game to have my powers 'tied behind my back'. All it takes is some thinking to realise how this rule can be abused by others - not myself. Second, I will ONLY agree to this if every other god agrees to the rule, and that would lead to the end of the game.))Norn wrote:Finally, I believe that Astavyastataa Kadna has put forth a wise suggestion. Would you consent to sealing the powers of malice and mutation within your borders to prevent any inadvertent spread?
This is what I have been getting at also. You know full well how you would react if something I created accidentally made its way to Nor Pupae, and cause problems for your followers! Yet you will not attempt to keep your creations confined, nor make amends when they do cause problems for others! Your spirit of negotiation is a joke!Nor Yekith wrote:((OOC: A wise suggestion? I'm not playing this game to have my powers 'tied behind my back'. All it takes is some thinking to realise how this rule can be abused by others - not myself. Second, I will ONLY agree to this if every other god agrees to the rule, and that would lead to the end of the game.))Norn wrote:Finally, I believe that Astavyastataa Kadna has put forth a wise suggestion. Would you consent to sealing the powers of malice and mutation within your borders to prevent any inadvertent spread?
Malice is in the intent. The cycles of nature, the food chain, contains no Malice. The Malice is in those who cause harm for the sake and pleasure of causing harm; for the sake and pleasure of causing terror, pain, and hopelessness in the victims. And for their god, the Malice is in receiving Power from that intended terror, pain, and hopelessness. You do not gain Power when one animal kills another for food, even if there is pain and fear. But you gain Power when one person kills another with the intent of causing pain and fear.Nor Yekith wrote:The hypocrisy!Bhakti wrote:Murder is murder. Rape is rape. Rage is rage. Fear is fear. Feeding off of those things is your choice.
Do you honestly sit there and believe the nonsense you write? How is it on the one hand you spout pretentious drivel and on the other you allow (nay, encourage it). You have taken, or represent, the realm of forests, yet forests are rife with the same things you accuse me of profiting from. Animals murder one another, they certainly have raped, they rage, they steal, they look down and destroy the weaker. This is the law of nature. Yet do you expect us to ignore that element that features so strongly in your realm?