I don't much disagree with the above at all, WF - unsurprising, since your deconstruct of the message of TCoTC pretty much mirrors mine.
Re the 1st Chrons, your summation is spot-on, IMHO. A confrontation with the dark side of one's psyche, a conflict is never going to work. There's no point trying to
destroy one's appetite for destruction - such an attempt would clearly and ironically be futilely self-defeating.
Re the 2nd Chrons, you use the word "acceptance" re the conclusion, which I'm not sure is entirely right. I - and SRD himself somewhere, from memory - used the word "surrender", but I don't think that's entirely without problems either. TC chooses the polarised opposite end of the strategy he used in TPTP - namely, in WGW, he chooses complete
passivity, or inaction if you'd rather, as contrasted with the pure aggression and action that he tried - equally ineffectively, as it turned out over the longterm - in TPTP. This isn't "surrender" in the sense that TC gives up and gives himself over to his dark side, ceding control, which is why I'm uneasy with potential confusion within the term. It is however true that at the end of the 2nd Chrons, TC has "accepted" that he cannot beat LF in a head-to-head.
As to the Last Chrons, IMHO, you're back to being spot-on - your usage of the term "incorporation" is well-made, as is the term "consume" (though I think it's a little more "subsume", but anyway). This to me - and again from somewhere, I seem to remember SRD using the term with reference to the Last Chrons, but I may be mistaken - is more of an "acceptance", in that TC has finally come to the realisation that neither confrontation nor passivity can provide any permanent solution. I don't think TC's "mastered" LF as such - it's clearly going to be an ongoing and eternal battle, but a purely internal one - however, he has achieved the only possible resolution. Only an acceptance and a subsequent incorporation will succeed - it's the mid-point resolution between conflict and passivity and harks back to the importance of balance, the "eye of the paradox", which is something that has always fascinated SRD and that he has felt is highly significant. Shades of the desirability of balance as mentioned in my Taoist yin-yang musings elsewhere.
Of course there are also clear connotations back to the nature of white gold, which has such overweening power and which can create "perfect works", solely (and paradoxically) because it is an imperfect alloy. Mhoram may have told TC that "you are the white gold", but the final melding - and yes, incorporation - of imperfections surely only happens when TC and LF are unified. As we've both said, it's that ultimate alloying which gives TC the power to rebuild the world. TC has become far more than a sacrificial lamb (which he kind of was at the end of WGW... more on this later) - he both loses and gains in his final individuation (thanks again, Herr Jung). As stated above, in becoming whole, in melding himself finally with his negative aspect, he is ever-fated to be in internal conflict - but importantly with full foreknowledge of this. After all, forewarned is of course forearmed. However, he's gained knowledge and thus efficacious power, a power that is now capable of remaking all things.
(As a brief side-note, the Last Chrons actually are IMHO an obviously far more profound examination of the central tenet to be found within my only partly tongue-in-cheek referenced Star Trek episode...
)
wayfriend wrote:Now he can finally harness those dark strengths, they are his to control. To use them only when it is a proper use, and to suppress them when it would be misapplied. For other strengths, he still has himself as well -- he is still the white gold. And where that is not enough, he has his love, Linden, who completes him in other ways.
With wild magic, and an inner Despiser, and a living love, Covenant is now truly and finally whole. And he is now finally capable of acting like a Creator, rebuilding the world in an image that is his.
Very nicely and appropriately put - I completely concur. Though on reflection, I might add that I'm not sure that TC rebuilds the world "in an image that is his" - unless of course one has decided that the whole world is a backdrop entirely springing from TC's inner subconscious. Anyhow, that's a minor quibble.
wayfriend wrote:. The triumvirate -- Covenant, Creator, Despiser -- has been unified.
Again, largely yes, agreed. I'd take this point on a little further. There are obviously quasi-religious overtones perceivable, looking at TCoTC as a whole - your reference to "triumvirate" could equally have been described as "trinity". But I think SRD's message is far more humanist than Christian... it's not vehemently anti-Christian as such, it's just that it goes beyond Christianity. Here's how I view it.
It's possible to see the resolution to the 1st Chrons as smacking of the Old Testament a bit - like the wrathful and vengeful God of the Old Testament, TC's attempted solution is to rain fire down on LF like God did on Sodom and Gomorrah. It's even more possible to see the resolution to the 2nd Chrons as mirroring the New Testament more closely, in that, much like Jesus, by remaining passive at the dénouement, TC sacrifices himself to save the world. However, SRD clearly shows us that this isn't the final solution either.
And so we reach the Last Chrons, where in stark contrast to core messages of Christianity, TC absolutely doesn't "renounce sin". He absolutely doesn't say "Get thee behind me, Satan" and absolutely doesn't "let the Lord Jesus into his heart" - in fact in many ways, he does the exact reverse, in that he
also accepts "Satan" and incorporates him into his "heart". BUT CRUCIALLY the control and responsibility for such remain entirely TC's... he absolutely does NOT surrender to his negative side, nor in any way gives into his darker impulses. This is a very humanist message - in walking the tightrope, finding the balancing point between the Divine and the Diabolic, arriving at the eye of the paradox between the Creator and the Despiser, TC becomes truly whole and achieves his full potential. In so doing, he comes to exemplify all the polarised facets, all the conflicting drives that are what it is to be quintessentially human. That's his "apotheosis", except that's entirely the wrong word - TC doesn't become a god at all... he becomes completely human. At this point, I am strongly reminded of the SRD quote in Z's signature which reads:
SRD wrote:Meaning is created internally by each individual in each specific life: any attempt at *meaning* which relies on some kind of external superstructure (God, Satan, the Creator, the Worm, whatever) for its substance misses the point (I mean the point of my story)
And that surely points the way to the over-riding message of the entirety of TCoTC... there are no external solutions. The entire 10 book work ends in a victory for humanity and it's only there, within each one of us, with an acknowledgement and integration of all that we are, for good and for ill, that a true resolution can be found. When faced with the ever-growing entropy of the cosmos, with the randomness of existence, we don't need gods - because they don't exist. The very concept of an external deity, an external "superstructure" is in fact meaningless to our existence. We just need ourselves - because that's all that there is. And that's enough... it suffices.
wayfriend wrote:I finally got around to reading this thread, as it is oft recommended. (Pointing at you, u.) I think I got rickrolled, though - somehow I ended up listening to "Never Gonna Like The Ending" again.
Hey! Just because I can (hopefully intellectually) appreciate and discuss SRD's metaphysical philosophy doesn't mean that I am duty-bound to love the way that he constructed the narrative vehicle for his message.