KaosArcana wrote:I don't think that Fist is right here.
There's a lot of folks here who disagree with my theories on the
Haruchai. You'll have to get in line.
KaosArcana wrote:I don't think any person of the Land could have duplicated the Haruchai's gifts... I think that's like saying a regular horse could have duplicated the Ranyhn's gifts if it just had a Ranyhn's mindset.
I'll go along with that. Consciousness and the ability to choose are the key. A horse acts according to its nature. It can't behave other than it does. But the Ranyhyn
can behave otherwise, yet they
choose to act as they do. Unlike my world, the decision to be true is rewarded in the Land.
KaosArcana wrote:The Haruchai were a different breed than a regular Land person.
Therefore, I disagree. Yes, my theory is based on my desire to have purity, discipline, and truth rewarded. I know it's not supported by anything SRD wrote, but neither is it contradicted. And so I'm free to hold on to my hope. In comic books, Shang Chi and Iron Fist are two
superb martial artists. Shang grew up in an ideal atmosphere, wanting to become the best he could, partly out of his love for his father. (He later learned that his love was badly misplaced.) Fist wanted to learn so that he could avenge the murders of his parents. When asked who the best martial artist in that world is, I say Shang, because I think more highly of his motivation. Again, it doesn't work like that in my world, but it would be nice if such things were rewarded
somewhere.
KaosArcana wrote:Hmm... unless maybe Berek Halfhand's battle prowess actually WERE as good as Atirian's song said ...

Always tough to know what to believe. We get some important information from these legends, and even from the Ravers! Reliable? When touched by
samadhi, Mhoram learned that their "knowledge" of the Colossus, which came from such legends, was wrong.