Posted: Fri Aug 31, 2007 8:24 pm
I have commented before how Kevin's Dirt seems to be very helpful to the Masters' strategy. In fact, that strategy probably wouldn't have worked without Kevin's Dirt on hand.
Official Discussion Forum for the works of Stephen R. Donaldson
https://kevinswatch.com/phpBB3/
Emotional Leper wrote:Maybe all that unused earthpower is backing up in the drainage pipes and getting very nasty and spilling out onto the streets, like A Florida town during a Hurricane?
Didn't the Bloodguard despair in a form when they dropped the Vow?Relayer wrote: But that still doesn't make a lot of sense. It certainly demonstrates how much judgement the Haruchai still hold towards Kevin (or to all those who despair).
What's THOOLAH?Stonemaybe wrote: Probably TC's fault. linden's too pure and too good to be assosiated with any type of dirt (Come on, where are you foolish Thoolah's?
Kevin's Dirt is another arrogant product of Elohim, Inc.wayfriend wrote:(At the risk of being predictable) This was posted yesterday.
In the Gradual Interview was wrote:Jim K: As always, thank you for writing. I am reading Runes for the second time and want to know....
Are the Bloodguard part of the problem of Kevin's Dirt?
In other words, is their denial of Earthpower towards the common folk causing the phenomenon?
[...] thanks again. Jim K
- No, the Haruchai share no responsibility for the existence of Kevin's Dirt. They don't do any magic. Withholding or stifling knowledge isn't the same thing as manipulating or tarnishing Earthpower. If asked, they might say that they consider Earthpower sacred: too sacred to be (mis)used by fallible human beings.
(02/28/2007)
Well, that busts a hole in my theory.
I couldn't agree more, and until I read this comment was about to post something similar. To me it is another indication of SRD's rushed form of writing in the Last Chronicles, a lack of thought for applicable names and real story development. In the somewhat archaic fashion that the Masters/Haruchai speak, the word 'Dirt' is very unlikely to have been chosen. "Kevin's Bane" or "Kevin's Scourge" would seem more likely (or equally any of the above suggestions).The name grates on my sensibilities. It seems almost juvenile and a little too pedestrian for SRD. If you're going to call it "Kevin's Dirt" why not just call it "Kevin's stuff that blinds your health sense"?!?!
I wish SRD could have come up with a more ominous appelation like "Kevin's Stain" or "Kevin's Shroud" or "Kevin's Pall". Anything but Kevin's "DIRT"!!!
Good lord. Is this what criticism of the Last Chrons has come to?TheSeventhWard wrote:I couldn't agree more, and until I read this comment was about to post something similar. To me it is another indication of SRD's rushed form of writing in the Last Chronicles, a lack of thought for applicable names and real story development. In the somewhat archaic fashion that the Masters/Haruchai speak, the word 'Dirt' is very unlikely to have been chosen. "Kevin's Bane" or "Kevin's Scourge" would seem more likely (or equally any of the above suggestions).The name grates on my sensibilities. It seems almost juvenile and a little too pedestrian for SRD. If you're going to call it "Kevin's Dirt" why not just call it "Kevin's stuff that blinds your health sense"?!?!
I wish SRD could have come up with a more ominous appelation like "Kevin's Stain" or "Kevin's Shroud" or "Kevin's Pall". Anything but Kevin's "DIRT"!!!
It's a pity, but I just see this as evidence that SRD is just trying to create an income for himself by shoehorning any idea that comes to him into an already perfectly complete saga.
Cambo wrote:Well, the people of the Land didn't name it, they don't even know it exists. The Masters did, and they don't use slang much.
That said, I don't have a problem with the name Kevin's Dirt, it even seems to fit the Masters quite well. Haruchai are pretty straight up, call a stone a stone guys. Stain, Shroud, Pall, Stain, Scourge...I dunno, I think they're just too literal minded. What does it look like? Looks like dirt. What does it do? It twists Earthpower into evil use. Oh, you mean like Kevin did? Let's call it Kevin's Dirt.
"Dirt" also seems a lot less threatening then "Bane" or "Scourge" or "Pall". If it's just Dirt, it may be inconvenient, but it can be lived with.TheSeventhWard wrote:I couldn't agree more, and until I read this comment was about to post something similar. To me it is another indication of SRD's rushed form of writing in the Last Chronicles, a lack of thought for applicable names and real story development. In the somewhat archaic fashion that the Masters/Haruchai speak, the word 'Dirt' is very unlikely to have been chosen. "Kevin's Bane" or "Kevin's Scourge" would seem more likely (or equally any of the above suggestions).The name grates on my sensibilities. It seems almost juvenile and a little too pedestrian for SRD. If you're going to call it "Kevin's Dirt" why not just call it "Kevin's stuff that blinds your health sense"?!?!
I wish SRD could have come up with a more ominous appelation like "Kevin's Stain" or "Kevin's Shroud" or "Kevin's Pall". Anything but Kevin's "DIRT"!!!
It's a pity, but I just see this as evidence that SRD is just trying to create an income for himself by shoehorning any idea that comes to him into an already perfectly complete saga.
Agree with Cam...to those who see it, it looks like dirt. If we're gonna argue mundane...well, dump Kevin's WATCH...and how boring to call great big folk Giants.TheWormoftheWorld'sEnd wrote:Cambo wrote:Well, the people of the Land didn't name it, they don't even know it exists. The Masters did, and they don't use slang much.
That said, I don't have a problem with the name Kevin's Dirt, it even seems to fit the Masters quite well. Haruchai are pretty straight up, call a stone a stone guys. Stain, Shroud, Pall, Stain, Scourge...I dunno, I think they're just too literal minded. What does it look like? Looks like dirt. What does it do? It twists Earthpower into evil use. Oh, you mean like Kevin did? Let's call it Kevin's Dirt.Spoiler
Tsunami.
Try 30 years ago.Vraith wrote:Agree with Cam...to those who see it, it looks like dirt. If we're gonna argue mundane...well, dump Kevin's WATCH...and how boring to call great big folk Giants.TheWormoftheWorld'sEnd wrote:Cambo wrote:Well, the people of the Land didn't name it, they don't even know it exists. The Masters did, and they don't use slang much.
That said, I don't have a problem with the name Kevin's Dirt, it even seems to fit the Masters quite well. Haruchai are pretty straight up, call a stone a stone guys. Stain, Shroud, Pall, Stain, Scourge...I dunno, I think they're just too literal minded. What does it look like? Looks like dirt. What does it do? It twists Earthpower into evil use. Oh, you mean like Kevin did? Let's call it Kevin's Dirt.Spoiler
Tsunami.
Spoiler
There's nothing exotic or unusual in the word tsunami, Worm. It is, quite literally, what it is, and common even in English, and succinct.
TheWormoftheWorld'sEnd wrote:Try 30 years ago.Vraith wrote:Agree with Cam...to those who see it, it looks like dirt. If we're gonna argue mundane...well, dump Kevin's WATCH...and how boring to call great big folk Giants.TheWormoftheWorld'sEnd wrote:Spoiler
Tsunami.
Spoiler
There's nothing exotic or unusual in the word tsunami, Worm. It is, quite literally, what it is, and common even in English, and succinct.
No, I'm saying that the word has only recently come into parlance.Cambo wrote:TheWormoftheWorld'sEnd wrote:Try 30 years ago.Vraith wrote: Agree with Cam...to those who see it, it looks like dirt. If we're gonna argue mundane...well, dump Kevin's WATCH...and how boring to call great big folk Giants.
Spoiler
There's nothing exotic or unusual in the word tsunami, Worm. It is, quite literally, what it is, and common even in English, and succinct.Spoiler
You mean it was common thirty years ago? I hear about tsunamis all time, I'm living in a city at great risk from them. A few years ago one of our neighbouring countries suffered from what came to be called "The Boxing Day Tsunami." Also, I agree with Vraith: there's no simpler way to say it that accurately conveys what it is. Like Dirt.
In which country?Cambo wrote:Oh, I see. Well, what did they call it before they called it aSpoiler
tsunami?