JonasKyratzes wrote:Excuse me, but music (with lyrics) by a band would completely ruin a Covenant movie. I mean, here we are in this magical fantasy world full of profound things, and suddenly we hear a pop song (from Earth)? Just because a song is good doesn't mean it should be put into a movie.
Some people wanted Led Zeppelin music in the LOTR movie. Can you imagine what it would have been like? It would have completely destroyed the atmosphere!
Just my 2 silver pieces.
I have to agree completely with Jonas.
I notice that everyone is talking about songs, but songs, while appropriate here and there, won't carry an epic fantasy series. The symphonic genre, with all of its themes and compositions, stands a much better chance of doing so.
The problem with pop music is that what is pop is by definition temporary.
A good case in point is the recent 'Narnia' soundtrack. With several pop songs thrown in with the score the album received general boos - see Amazon.com if you don't believe it. A clear majority of soundtracks that continue to sell more than a year after release are symphonic.
That aside, everyone's taste is different, and while all of us can enjoy scenes with symphonic music, many do not necessarily like pop, 'new age' (how long will that be 'new'?) or rap, hip-hop, or whatever.
You don't want the music in a scene to be embarassing 10 years on when tastes have changed...