Posted: Wed Mar 17, 2010 11:53 am
Happy Birthday, Xar!!
Official Discussion Forum for the works of Stephen R. Donaldson
https://kevinswatch.com/phpBB3/
The AllFather precedes time and the measurement thereof. Only one outside of time could command Koel.Stonemaybe wrote:Do we REALLy have a birth date for the Allfather????
Now that is Truthfully stated.The Numen wrote:He chooses to phrase his commands as statements. He is no less in charge.
Anything you care to share, Murrin?Murrin wrote:Ha.
Menolly wrote:Anything you care to share, Murrin?Murrin wrote:Ha.
...yeah, yeah, I know. Dream on...
Ha.Menolly wrote:But he chooses to command none of us...
I meant, anything you care to share regarding that "Ha" in response to me saying The AllFather chooses to command none of us...Murrin wrote:(So, uh, the concept is, posts below respond to those above. Tough, I know.)
Arcadia wrote:Surely, the All-Father controls and commands one of our nearest and dearest -
Zephyr.
That's pretty similar to what I have heard...Murrin wrote:Just, ah, don't bother trying not to do what he wants you to. It can be entertaining, but it's not very good for your plans.
I know you are, but what am I.Arcadia wrote:Surely, the All-Father controls and commands one of our nearest and dearest -
Zephyr.
As is only appropriate for one who is to us mere gods as we are to mere mortals, the AllFather does not stoop to the mere giving of commands and the expectation of obedience. He takes an approach that is far beyond, but similar in form to what George Orwell described in 1984, when he theorized that by limiting the vocabulary of the people, Big Brother could limit their ability to even conceive of disloyalty. By deciding on the shape of the world in which we exist, the AllFather may dictate to us our actions, and we will all act the way he "commands" us to, all entirely of our own free wills. This is beyond obedience or disobedience. We simply perform his bidding.Menolly wrote:hmm...
I was hoping more for details as to why you feel "Ha" sums up your feelings regarding that. But, cool.
I don't see being ultimately in charge necessarily as commanding the players; while we may not succeed at something, we are allowed to try various things of our own imagination. So, I disagree with the assessment that he does command us.
But I have heard of some players who justifiably may disagree with that...
OR, perhaps you just ....I'm not even gonna finish that sentence, otherwise Brid'll get such a kick up the...The Numen wrote:As is only appropriate for one who is to us mere gods as we are to mere mortals, the AllFather does not stoop to the mere giving of commands and the expectation of obedience. He takes an approach that is far beyond, but similar in form to what George Orwell described in 1984, when he theorized that by limiting the vocabulary of the people, Big Brother could limit their ability to even conceive of disloyalty. By deciding on the shape of the world in which we exist, the AllFather may dictate to us our actions, and we will all act the way he "commands" us to, all entirely of our own free wills. This is beyond obedience or disobedience. We simply perform his bidding.Menolly wrote:hmm...
I was hoping more for details as to why you feel "Ha" sums up your feelings regarding that. But, cool.
I don't see being ultimately in charge necessarily as commanding the players; while we may not succeed at something, we are allowed to try various things of our own imagination. So, I disagree with the assessment that he does command us.
But I have heard of some players who justifiably may disagree with that...