Posted: Tue Dec 22, 2015 6:12 am
Enjoy Outlander, Av.
The series should keep you busy for awhile...
The series should keep you busy for awhile...
Official Discussion Forum for the works of Stephen R. Donaldson
https://kevinswatch.com/phpBB3/
I am quite. Just ordered the next two books, but will only get them next month.Menolly wrote:More than halfway through the current books in the series then. Are you enjoying the story, Av?
Just finished this as well, enjoyable, good writing and with some good ideas around AI. Parts of it do seem a bit naive, but the context of the story may allow for some of that. However, with the general awareness of the possibility of the Singularity etc. you'd think that people would be a bit more careful/cagey around such a big step. There also seemed to be some fairly basic discussions around how we develop awareness, the importance of socialisation and language that seemed very ad hoc. You'd hope that that kind of thing would be tested and developed before you start dumping intelligences into machines. Or, given the general way that humans go about things, maybe not. Oops!Fist and Faith wrote:Just read Stephen Palmer's Beautiful Intelligence... Artificial Intelligence, next-generation internet, crazy fun stuff. Some good discussions about consciousness/emotion/intelligence.
OTOH, scifi has had it come about in many accidental or emergent ways that aren't intended. Certainly not tested and developed.ussusimiel wrote:You'd hope that that kind of thing would be tested and developed before you start dumping intelligences into machines. Or, given the general way that humans go about things, maybe not. Oops!
Not a couple centuries from now it ain't!Avatar wrote:Ghana is a parliamentary democracy...
--A
I suppose what I was trying to say was that if the world is set in the future from our current present then it would include all the speculation etc. that SF has come up with so far. Of course, in a sci-fi/fantasy world that doesn't have to be a given, but directly invoking something like the Internet does, for me, set up certain expectations. It's wasn't that much of a problem, and it fit somewhat with the general fragility and naivety of some of the central characters.Fist and Faith wrote:OTOH, scifi has had it come about in many accidental or emergent ways that aren't intended. Certainly not tested and developed.ussusimiel wrote:You'd hope that that kind of thing would be tested and developed before you start dumping intelligences into machines. Or, given the general way that humans go about things, maybe not. Oops!
I didn't know there were any more, I'll keep an eye out for them, thanks!Fist and Faith wrote: Did you read beyond the first book? The second is a short novel. The third is very interesting...
I don't think the internet - actually the nexus - was much involved with the AI. One was a quantum computer, and the other was the biograins. But anyway, I don't understand what you mean in your first post. How can we test and develop the importance of socialization and language to the development of awareness in any way other than trying to use them to create an awareness?ussusimiel wrote:I suppose what I was trying to say was that if the world is set in the future from our current present then it would include all the speculation etc. that SF has come up with so far. Of course, in a sci-fi/fantasy world that doesn't have to be a given, but directly invoking something like the Internet does, for me, set up certain expectations. It's wasn't that much of a problem, and it fit somewhat with the general fragility and naivety of some of the central characters.Fist and Faith wrote:OTOH, scifi has had it come about in many accidental or emergent ways that aren't intended. Certainly not tested and developed.ussusimiel wrote:You'd hope that that kind of thing would be tested and developed before you start dumping intelligences into machines. Or, given the general way that humans go about things, maybe not. Oops!
You edited the other titles out of my post in your quote.ussusimiel wrote:I didn't know there were any more, I'll keep an eye out for them, thanks!Fist and Faith wrote: Did you read beyond the first book? The second is a short novel. The third is very interesting...
I presume that there are plenty of steps that you can take from computer simulation, to basic robots, to more complicated systems etc. There is also the matter of size and power, never mind giving a new consciousness access to the Nexus/Internet. What I'd be suggesting is that you start off small and scale up gradually: great power/great responsibility etc.Fist and Faith wrote:But anyway, I don't understand what you mean in your first post. How can we test and develop the importance of socialization and language to the development of awareness in any way other than trying to use them to create an awareness?
Missed that! I thought they were totally different books you were talking about, it being Christmas and allFist and Faith wrote:You edited the other titles out of my post in your quote.ussusimiel wrote:I didn't know there were any more, I'll keep an eye out for them, thanks!Fist and Faith wrote: Did you read beyond the first book? The second is a short novel. The third is very interesting...