Nav- is there any chance you can turn Loremaster's image into a link? It breaks the tables in the forum and makes posts hard to read, and that makes me a sad panda.
I am still playing, but here's how it is, the "nitty gritty" if you will:
The game is good. In fact, I believe it has the potential to be one of the best I've ever played.
Now, I am NOT one to bitch about bugs in a new game. They happen, and I am used to that. It's cool. It's fine. It's the way MMO's work. They're never finished at launch.
With that in mind- had Vanguard had 6 months of extra work before it launched, it STILL would have been one of the buggiest launches I've ever played through. And I've played through a lot. This game has found some of the most exciting and new ways to crash on me. I've used the /stuck command more times in the last couple weeks then I'd previously used in my entire life. I have screenshots of color glitches that would make you wonder if I wasn't playing with ultra violet glasses on, or if I wasn't playing some weird Scanner Darkly game.
The game is three major things. The first two will eventually be fixed. The third is inherent to the game and I hope it will never change. The game is A- Buggy as hell. B- Too resource intensive for what it is. And C- Hard. It's not WoW. It's much more like EQ1. You CAN solo, they did that right, but you're not going to grind to 50 in two weeks, or three, or even a month. You wouldn't want to anyway, because there isn't high end content right now.
Unfortunately, because of those three things, the game is also severely underpopulated. It could be better on other (non PvP) servers, but for me finding groups can be like pulling teeth. Hell, getting my teeth pulled in the past has been more pleasant- at least the dentist gives me drugs to deal with the pain.
"But Aunty Waddley! Why are you still playing the game if you say so many bad things about it??"
I actually like the game. I like the quest system. I like the combat system. I like equipment, I like the skills, I like the graphics (when I turn them up for a screenshot, and just before my game crashes). I like boats, I like the promise of boat combat. I like challenge of the level grind, I love the boys in my guild. I like the atmosphere of particular zones. I like taking boats to get from one place to another. I like the pretty red barding on my horse. I like how groups interact. I like the random PvP of my Teams server.
I'd like it all to actually be playable someday, too.
So there you go, Nav

If you want to give it a try, I have a 10 day trial I can give ya. Just lemme know.