Nominations for Best User-created Image, 2011
Posted: Sun Aug 05, 2012 8:32 pm
Nominations accepted:
Frostheart - Charade's End
Marineguy - Saltheart & Covenant
Frostheart - Charade's End
Marineguy - Saltheart & Covenant
Official Discussion Forum for the works of Stephen R. Donaldson
https://kevinswatch.com/phpBB3/
secondedwayfriend wrote:I nominate Frostheart for Charade's End.
Oooops. Withdrawn.I'm Murrin wrote:As good as it is, it looks like that one was uploaded in 2012.
Is this posted on the Watch anywhere?wayfriend wrote:I nominate Frostheart for Charade's End.
It was prior to Frostheart's (fine...Zorm's) hiatus. Many treasures were taken down at that time and not all have come back to the Watch...but those who Watch remember. Clearly, Way is among that group...and none are surprised thereby!Menolly wrote:Is this posted on the Watch anywhere?wayfriend wrote:I nominate Frostheart for Charade's End.
Accepted on my part. We'll see what the Sheriff says.Savor Dam wrote:Yes, I admit this is neither a nom nor a second, since Frosty's image has already received both. Before a Great and Powerful Watchy Mod banishes my post, I humbly point out that it is answering a question posed by a Watchy Mod...
Seconded.Frostheart wrote:Marineguy's Saltheart & Covenant. kevinswatch.ihugny.com/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=21095 (Wish it were bigger, can hardly see the details.)
As hilarious as it is, this has been posted on several occasions during several different years (HLT's repost is from Jul 23, 2010). Mods, I think we need some sort of rule here: First posting year or latest appearance?Effaeldm wrote:I nominate "Don't touch me" Tommy
The thread is from 2011, should count as the date it appeared on the forum.
Thanks for elucidating. Perhaps this particular nomination would fit better the 2010 awards (than the suggested 2011), considering the original post date of the thread.[Syl Embattled] wrote:As long as it was posted, used, or whatever during the 2010-2011 period, I think it's eligible for nomination. However, I would suggest against repeats or reposts because I doubt they'd get that many votes.
Also, is the copy writ creator of the image, Russel Flowers, a Watcher? Or was the image manipulated in any way by the Watcher who posted it? I'm not sure how we would award a Watchy to Russel Flowers if the answer is no to either question.[Syl Embattled] wrote:As long as it was posted, used, or whatever during the 2010-2011 period, I think it's eligible for nomination. However, I would suggest against repeats or reposts because I doubt they'd get that many votes.