Probably a stupid question...
Posted: Sat Nov 13, 2004 5:58 am
Has anybody figured out what the deuce the Durance and skurj are?
Official Discussion Forum for the works of Stephen R. Donaldson
https://kevinswatch.com/phpBB3/
For at that time was a peril upon the Earth to which we could not close our eyes. In the farthest north of the world, where winter has its roots of ice and cold, a fire had been born among the foundations of the firmament. I do not speak of the cause of that fire, but only of its jeopardy to the Earth. Such was its site and virulence that it threatened to rive the shell of the world.
The Skurj seem to be made reference to in concert with the Durance, my personal opinion are they are the firelike creatures Linden saw in her vision riving the earth. I think they were the creatures originally responsible for the fire in the north (like the Arghule were for the cold - with the help of the Croyel in WGW). They were bound by the Durance and when Kastenessen escaped/was freed as Esmer implied the creatures escaped. It was also mentioned that they found release in Mount Thunder, which leads me to suspect some connection with the Fire Lions.Because of his dispair we were compelled to bind him to his place, reaving him of name and choice and time to set him as a keystone for the threatened foundation of the north. Thus was the fire capped, and the Earth preserved, and Kastenessen lost.
Very good summary. What do you think would have broken the Durance? I've thought perhaps an errant ceasure but perhaps it was Esmer! And then if the Skurj made a deal with the Croyel .... *shudders* And with Raver infected Sandgorgons... *shudders again* LF may not be the largest of the Earth's problems. Perhaps he whispered a word to Esmer, the Skurj, the Sandgorgons ...ScrapOSamadhi wrote:A serious reply for a changebut not a certain one.
From various references the Durance appears to refer to the (unwilling) binding the Elohim Kastenessen underwent to cap the harm in the north:
For at that time was a peril upon the Earth to which we could not close our eyes. In the farthest north of the world, where winter has its roots of ice and cold, a fire had been born among the foundations of the firmament. I do not speak of the cause of that fire, but only of its jeopardy to the Earth. Such was its site and virulence that it threatened to rive the shell of the world.The Skurj seem to be made reference to in concert with the Durance, my personal opinion are they are the firelike creatures Linden saw in her vision riving the earth. I think they were the creatures originally responsible for the fire in the north (like the Arghule were for the cold - with the help of the Croyel in WGW). They were bound by the Durance and when Kastenessen escaped/was freed as Esmer implied the creatures escaped. It was also mentioned that they found release in Mount Thunder, which leads me to suspect some connection with the Fire Lions.Because of his dispair we were compelled to bind him to his place, reaving him of name and choice and time to set him as a keystone for the threatened foundation of the north. Thus was the fire capped, and the Earth preserved, and Kastenessen lost.
Hope this helps.
Don't tell me about stupid people, I work in tech supportJD wrote:There are no stupid questions, just stupid people! Just kidding
I can think of several reasons Kastenessen’s binding might not have endured:What do you think would have broken the Durance? I've thought perhaps an errant ceasure but perhaps it was Esmer!
Good possibilities. I can think of some more:Aleksandr wrote:I can think of several reasons Kastenessen’s binding might not have endured:What do you think would have broken the Durance? I've thought perhaps an errant ceasure but perhaps it was Esmer!
1. He was unwilling, thus it was flawed from the start. (Yes, Findail was less than eager too, but recall that at the very last in WGW he accepted his fate).
2. The laws of Life and Death are both broken. Maybe this helped weakened his binding.
3. The creation of a new Staff of Law somehow left a weakness or gap in the old Law that allowed Kastenessen to get free
4. The caesures have weakened the biding by their damage to the Arch.
I’ve seen this stated in several threads and I’m not sure it’s accurate. We are told after all that anything inside a caesure exists across all the instants of time which the caesure contains. So the Staff wasn’t really absent (through it was not available for anyone’s active use); it was simply inaccessible, just as the old Staff was when it was lying lost under Mt Thunder.The weakness or gap in the Law occurred because Linden plucked the Staff out of the past, leaving a long gap in time without it.