Kevin's Watch

...has been brought up for years by fan-boys in another major franchise (not Donaldson, but another auteur) of note...and there's no such thing as 'bad-press'...

Hmmmm ... seems like a harsh title ...

I'm sorry, but I don't understand either the title or the introductory post. Please elaborate.

As I see it, Glaive is stating that on other boards he's been to, he's heard people say, "Donaldson raped my childhood," probably more or less verbatim, considering the quotation marks. It's understandable. A lot of us (myself included) found the Chronicles quite young and by accident. I think at the time I found the Chrons in the fantasy section of my local library, I had read Tolkien, Pern, Xanth, Dragonlance, and maybe Eddings. I know I wasn't prepared for what happened in LFB (and as a result, just didn't think about it that much).

But just because I understand the statement, doesn't make it fair. Donaldson himself has said he doesn't believe people that young should read the books. It's not his fault where his books get shelved (heck, a lot of libraries put the majority of fantasy in YA). It's not his fault my mom never bothered to find out what I was reading.

I agree with Syl completely! And as we've heard from other posters who've read it young, it has not disturbed THEIR childhood.

I also think the way SRD describes Covenant's reaction show's that this was a despicable act that Covenant was ashamed of and spent much of his time in the Land trying to atone for it.

[BTW, the same statement about childhood could be made for reading ANY adult fiction; I would NOT have wanted to read the GAP series at a young age!!]

What franchise fans are the complainers?

Star Wars fans.
Sorry for the media switch, but on many film forums the cry of 'Lucas raped my childhood' is a commom one with his prequal series of Star Wars.

Just wondering if that sort of BS will birth here.

*blinks* That just sounds so silly. I was 10, maybe 11 the first time I read 1st and 2nd Chrons. And I loved them. Maybe I wasn't mature enough to fully understand the horror of rape, cause I had no serious problems with forgiving Covenant for it, but... In that case it was a good thing.

I am still trying to figure that one out. SW fans (including myself) rightly lament the prequel movies, b/c they are lousy in almost every respect except FX (and Natalie Portman). But SRD fans? I did not like the Lena rape scene either--I read it 3 times b/c I could not believe what had happened--I was sure I had misinterpreted it. I was revolted and it took me a long time to have any positive feelings for TC.

OK, maybe I am dense here. Are you suggesting that SRD has lost his narrative voice and is ruining the TC series? Or are you saying that you liked Runes and hope that similar fan misgivings don't arise with Runes?

aiken wrote:
OK, maybe I am dense here. Are you suggesting that SRD has lost his narrative voice and is ruining the TC series? Or are you saying that you liked Runes and hope that similar fan misgivings don't arise with Runes?

The latter.

I think it is inevitable that some people who read the most recent stuff will be horrified/disappointed/pissed off because you will never please everyone all of the time. And people have had a very long time to interpret the frist two series the way they personally want. Have SRD come back and possibly redefine their understanding of it might jar, on the other hand it might fit like a glove.

Horses and courses, I believe. It is exactly what it happening with Star Wars - except of course the new SW are also badly executed, nevermind the actual story ideas behind them.

No raping here - the love affair continues!

First read LFB aged around 14 I guess, finished the whole 1st and 2nd Chronicles within a year. Boy, did those novels save my life! From the dark depths of my depression Donaldson taught me that we can derive real-life knowledge about ourselves and our relationships to each other and the world we live in. TCoTC has probably done more to keep me sane than any amount of counselling I could have received.

Just hoping the Last Chronicles is up to scratch. Currently on page 350 of Runes, and it's all good so far....

One of my daughters is currently reading LFB. I asked her last night, "So -- did you read Chapter 7 yet?"

She said, "I'm on Chapter 9 now."

I said, "Ah, you're past the rape, then. So what do you think of Covenant -- is he an annoying git?"

She said, "Pretty much, yeah."

I said, "Well, don't worry. So far, he's spent 7 books paying for it!"

Corruption wrote:First read LFB aged around 14 I guess, finished the whole 1st and 2nd Chronicles within a year. Boy, did those novels save my life! From the dark depths of my depression Donaldson taught me that we can derive real-life knowledge about ourselves and our relationships to each other and the world we live in. TCoTC has probably done more to keep me sane than any amount of counselling I could have received.
.

Interesting, without getting into details I also consider myself "saved" by the 1st Chronicles and also at around age 14!

I give credit to Mhoram though. He was the father figure that I didn't have. And I tried to handle my world getting turned upside down by Juvenile Diabetes that same year with the dispassion and attitude of a BloodGuard.
And of course, my appreciation of the beauty of the Earth just practically EXPLODED by the end of the 1st Chronicles.
I've never looked at a tree the same way since!
And I mean that in a good way not being afraid that I was going to get blasted by getting too close.

Donaldson too saved me from Teenaged depression. The chronicels made me realize that no matter how....worthless, or how much someone feels like they don't belong, everyone has a place, everyone belongs, and it's important not to be ruled by negative feelings, especially your own. My kids are way too young for the Chonicles...heck they're too young for the Hobbit, but the lessons I've taught myself from these books, I've used in my parenting.


-There. Not all of my posts have to be jokes!!

drew wrote:Donaldson too saved me from Teenaged depression. The chronicels made me realize that no matter how....worthless, or how much someone feels like they don't belong, everyone has a place, everyone belongs, and it's important not to be ruled by negative feelings, especially your own. My kids are way too young for the Chonicles...heck they're too young for the Hobbit, but the lessons I've taught myself from these books, I've used in my parenting.

I follow the WWCID program with my kids myself.
It's worked pretty well so far.
"What Would Charles Ingalls Do?"

drew wrote: There. Not all of my posts have to be jokes!!

"Joy is in the ears that hear"

I like that ALOT better that the WWMA(LF)D sceneo.

Spoiler

what would mr. avery (linden's father) do

*shudder* don't even want to contemplate that scenario

k, this is totally jumping back a subject or two here...but I think that the people who use the "raped my childhood" sentence don't understand rape.

After all, the only place you read a book you're not necessarily willing to read is in school (and even then, people choose, whether the teachers like it or not). Rape implies, no, declares that it is not done at the victim's will.
Yeah, I know...it's probably just a metaphor, and a hyperbolic one, at that...but it's not a very well thought out one, obviously.
In general, I don't think people here would even dream to use such a phrase in relation to Donaldson and his works...the man is too highly respected, and I think people know better than to think that.
I'm not trying to sound harsh *rueful grin* I just can't seem to find a way to write all that without the edge in the tone.

But folks, that phrase doesn't have to do anything with Lena's rape in LFB. What they basically say is that by creating the abysmal prequels Lucas has practically taken away their illusions and fantasies that they had experienced having seen the original SW films in the eighties of the last century.
Now I do not think that will happen to TCTC.