Page 1 of 3

Orson Welles & The War of the Worlds: Panic In America

Posted: Thu Jun 23, 2005 4:18 am
by matrixman
Today on the Discovery channel there was a broadcast of Martian Mania: The True Story of the War of the Worlds, hosted by James Cameron. The show explored Orson Welles's infamous radio broadcast on October 30, 1938 that convinced millions of terrified listeners in America that there was a real Martian invasion.

The program discussed the reasons, the circumstances, that allowed for a simple radio play to traumatize so many people.

To summarize some of the things said:

- radio in the 1930's was the dominant form of "home entertainment" in the U.S. One of the show's commentators said that radio at that time was what provided a nation of immigrants its identity as America. So radio had a captive and national audience.

- most of the sci-fi stories of that era were of the crude and cartoonish Buck Rogers and Flash Gordon variety, but Orson Welles intuitively understood sci-fi's dramatic potential. He realized that the persuasive power of radio when combined with the outlandish nature of a tall sci-fi tale could yield explosive results. He just didn't realize how explosive!

- the way Welles adapted War of the Worlds for radio was a stroke of brilliance, updating the setting to fit contemporary America. The play was disguised as a series of realistic sounding and unnerving news reports of some strange object crashing into a farm in Grover Mills, New Jersey...

As portions of the radio broadcast were played back, I have to say even I was a little spellbound by it! Especially by the voice of the fake news reporter who was describing for his listeners the sight of something sinister emerging from the crashed object. Add in the indistinct sounds of hissing and metal scraping, then unearthly shrieks and screams of panic from fleeing bystanders...and wow, I can understand how radio listeners everywhere were mesmerized. Your imagination fills in the blanks.

Perhaps the crowning touch for Welles was in hiring an actor who did a great impression of Franklin Roosevelt. He didn't portray FDR in the broadcast, just a "Secretary of the Interior" who suspiciously sounded like FDR. But the actor's performance was more than convincing. The real President Roosevelt was a fixture on the radio, after all; he frequently used radio to reach the country in a way that no other President before him ever had before, so just hearing someone that sounded like him warning the nation of the "gravity of the situation" was enough to convince listeners of the utter reality of a Martian invasion.

Host Cameron and the show's commentators believe that the Welles broadcast still holds relevance today as an example (and a warning) of how easily a master manipulator may use the media to dupe an unquestioning audience. As one person on the show said: "Give someone of the caliber of Orson Welles 10 minutes on CNN and he might fool the country into believing there's been an atomic attack."

Who knows? Maybe it could even be worse today, especially when you consider the rapid speed that rumours and false information can spread across the internet.

Here are some interesting links for "further reading":

The War of the Worlds -The Script -- the complete radio script as performed by Orson Welles and the Mercury Theatre

War of the Worlds Radio Broadcast Causes Panic -- a good summary of the event and the key players

War of the Worlds: How Orson Welles Drew the Nation into a Shared Illusion -- nice little article about the power of mass communications to create convincing illusions

The War of the Worlds in RealAudio -- you can supposedly listen to the original broadcast, but I don't use RealAudio so I haven't checked it out. I leave it up to you. :)

Posted: Thu Jun 23, 2005 5:13 am
by Loredoctor
There was no mass panic. Seriously, if you look at all the facts (there have been a number of studies):

1. The broadcast mentioned on three separate times that it was simply a play.

2. The broadcast covers a period of a couple of days (or a day). For instance, at one point the cylinder lands and then several hours later it opens. Time is moved along and the narrator is running away. As the broadcast did not last for hours, assuming that people would have been believed it is ridiculous.

3. The segment was advertised days before hand as a special - did people really think that Welles would have known Martians would invade at the time slot?

4. Radio plays were common form of entertainment back then; people knew they were listening to plays. It would be like broadcasting a tv 'documentary' about alien invasion today and expecting people to believe it. We wouldn't, and nor were people more gullible in Welle's time.

5. The effect of the play - the panic - has been distorted grossly. Some people say the city panicked, then others claim most of america panicked. There was no mass panic.

6. You don't interrupt a story of invasion of aliens with orchestral music. It would be like interrupting the invasion of america by terrorists with music video clips.

7. NONE of the hopsitals that night reported any victims of panic or had extra people coming in.

8. There are no police records of panic that night. Traffic records do not show extra traffic on the roads.

9. A witness who worked on a major bridge the night of the panic claimed that there was no extra traffic either. An interesting side note: there are no witnesses to a panic; strangely it is only the media.

10. Welles himself stated to the media there was a panic - that is the source of the story.

11. How come no other station reported the event? If your city is being invaded wouldn't you check other stations or talk to other people?

Posted: Thu Jun 23, 2005 5:14 am
by Loredoctor
kevinswatch.ihugny.com/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?p=244217#244217

Case concluded:
news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/science/nature/203924.stm

www.mssv.net/realityart/wotwarticle.html

Posted: Thu Jun 23, 2005 6:03 am
by matrixman
Case concluded? That's a cut-and-dry view of it. Oh well, if you're certain that I've been duped myself, there's nothing I can do about that.

Posted: Thu Jun 23, 2005 6:08 am
by Loredoctor
Matrixman wrote:Case concluded? That's a cut-and-dry view of it. Oh well, if you're certain that I've been duped myself, there's nothing I can do about that.
Were you duped, too, MM? My apologies, I did not realise you were there that night. Mythbusters pretty much do the same thing I just did, so I can imagine many people upset with the way they handle things, too ;)

Posted: Thu Jun 23, 2005 7:43 am
by Avatar
Without having read the articles yet, I wonder if the truth lies some indefinable distance into the middle? It's all too believeable that some people mistook it for reality, because as we all know, some people will believe anything. ;) The mass exodus of millions certainly seems exaggerated though.

--A

Posted: Thu Jun 23, 2005 8:49 am
by Loredoctor
Oh, I am the first to agree that some people panicked - there are records of such happening. But not a mass exodus.

Posted: Thu Jun 23, 2005 12:44 pm
by I'm Murrin
Loremaster wrote:Some people say the city panicked, then others claim most of america panicked. No one did.
Loremaster wrote:Oh, I am the first to agree that some people panicked - there are records of such happening.

Posted: Thu Jun 23, 2005 12:47 pm
by Avatar
That's not very nice Murrin. ;)

--A

Posted: Thu Jun 23, 2005 1:16 pm
by Loredoctor
Murrin wrote:
Loremaster wrote:Some people say the city panicked, then others claim most of america panicked. There was no mass panic.
Loremaster wrote:Oh, I am the first to agree that some people panicked - there are records of such happening.
My bad. I meant, no mass panic. After all, and you have edited out something important, I did state that there a gross exaggeration of panic.

Posted: Thu Jun 23, 2005 2:49 pm
by dANdeLION
Loremaster wrote:There was no mass panic. Seriously, if you look at all the facts (there have been a number of studies):

1. The broadcast mentioned on three separate times that it was simply a play.


Yeah, but we all knew those broadcasts stating the fakeness of the real broadcasts were really fake brodcasts from the aliens.
Loremaster wrote:2. The broadcast covers a period of a couple of days (or a day). For instance, at one point the cylinder lands and then several hours later it opens. Time is moved along and the narrator is running away. As the broadcast did not last for hours, assuming that people would have been believed it is ridiculous.
What you don't seem to understand is that the Martians operated outside the normal conventions of time and space. That fact explains a lot of things: 1) Why I was there in '38, 26 years before I was born; 2) Why the Martians were all driving DeLorians, and 3) Why Gary Coleman became famous.
Loremaster wrote:3. The segment was advertised days before hand as a special - did people really think that Welles would have known Martians would invade at the time slot?
Read my whole time/space continuum thing again; apparently you still don't get it.
Loremaster wrote:4. Radio plays were common form of entertainment back then; people knew they were listening to plays. It would be like broadcasting a tv 'documentary' about alien invasion today and expecting people to believe it. We wouldn't, and nor were people more gullible in Welle's time.
That's how clever the Martians were; they knew how to make it sound fake to us, while simultaneously making it sound real to us, while simultaneously braodcasting subliminal messages to their generals to coordinate their attack.
Loremaster wrote:5. The effect of the play - the panic - has been distorted grossly. Some people say the city panicked, then others claim most of america panicked. There was no mass panic.
I panicked during mass! If that isn't mass panick, I don't know what is!
Loremaster wrote:6. You don't interrupt a story of invasion of aliens with orchestral music. It would be like interrupting the invasion of america by terrorists with music video clips.
You have it all wrong......the story was interrupting the orchestra, and we do interrupt invasion news today with video clips of Micheal Jackson all the time.
Loremaster wrote:7. NONE of the hopsitals that night reported any victims of panic or had extra people coming in.
Because the Martians took over the hospitals, you knucklehead!
Loremaster wrote:8. There are no police records of panic that night. Traffic records do not show extra traffic on the roads.

The Police records were purged by the aliens, dude. Don't you ever watch the X-Files?
Loremaster wrote:9. A witness who worked on a major bridge the night of the panic claimed that there was no extra traffic either. An interesting side note: there are no witnesses to a panic; strangely it is only the media.
He was paid off, the bloody traitor. I know because I saw the DeLorian in his garage......
Loremaster wrote:10. Welles himself stated to the media there was a panic - that is the source of the story.
Welles was a Martian. C'mon, you HAD to see that coming!
Loremaster wrote:11. How come no other station reported the event? If your city is being invaded wouldn't you check other stations or talk to other people?
There was only one radio station in '38; didn't you know that?

Posted: Thu Jun 23, 2005 3:18 pm
by dANdeLION
Orrrrr......it could be that Orson Welles was a Nazi simpathiser who did his fake broadcast in order to get us so used to ignoring such broadcasts that we'd ignore the Pearl Harbor broadcast........and later the 9/11 broadcast. In fact, I do believe that several senators have fallen for this ploy.

Posted: Thu Jun 23, 2005 3:21 pm
by Loredoctor
LOL!! Both your posts are superb, sir! Superb!

I might add that despite Murrin's obligatory negative posts towards me, your posts have convinced me I am wrong!

Posted: Thu Jun 23, 2005 3:30 pm
by dANdeLION
I only posted once, Dances With Werewolves.

Posted: Thu Jun 23, 2005 3:30 pm
by dANdeLION
I posted thrice, Dances With Werewolves.

Posted: Thu Jun 23, 2005 3:32 pm
by dANdeLION
Murrin wrote:
dANdeLION wrote:I only posted once, Dances With Werewolves.
dANdeLION wrote:I posted thrice, Dances With Werewolves.
That's not very nice Murrin

Posted: Thu Jun 23, 2005 3:34 pm
by aTOMiC
anyone that can count can clearly see you double posted, Hairball.
Loremaster is correct.

Posted: Thu Jun 23, 2005 3:36 pm
by Loredoctor
dANdeLION wrote:
Murrin wrote:
dANdeLION wrote:I only posted once, Dances With Werewolves.
dANdeLION wrote:I posted thrice, Dances With Werewolves.
That's not very nice Murrin
It's LAST OF THE MOHICANS you stupid Tiger!

aTOMic - Merci

Posted: Thu Jun 23, 2005 3:37 pm
by dANdeLION
What if one were blind, yet knew how to count? Could he clearly see it then? Well, could he?



I didn't think so, Mr. Smartypants

Posted: Thu Jun 23, 2005 3:38 pm
by aTOMiC
dANdeLION wrote:What if one were blind, yet knew how to count? Could he clearly see it then> Well, could he?



I didn't think so, Mr. Smartypants

I'm not sure that makes any sense. I think you've had enough, dAN. Barkeep! Call this man a cab.