burgs wrote:I was going back and forth between The Briar King and Russell, but Donaldson's and Hobbs' blurb pulled me in.
I've had many experiences where i started reading a book and then either returned it to the library or the store, later to pick them up and love them?
Would you believe the two most infamous of these are The Hobbit and Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone??
I've learned, finally, never to judge something based on the first paragraph or first two pages.
That said, I read the first page of Shadowmarch while sitting in my car waiting to exit the parking lot, then turned back around and returned it. No regrets there. It sounded ridiculous, and the reviews on Amazon seem to agree.
Forgive me, but I saw your comments here on the aforementioned authors/books and figured I'd throw my two cents in...
Russell is one of my personal favorites, but "The Swans' War" trilogy isn't his best work, IMHO. Don't let that discourage you though, as I'd still consider it head and shoulders above a good deal of stuff in the genre.
If you like this trilogy, definitely check out his "River Into Darkness" and "Moontide and Magic Rise" books. Fantastic stuff.
"The Briar King" by Keyes is pretty good as well. Good start to another series. I believe the third book is due out in April if I'm not mistaken.
Finally: I can't blame you for taking "Shadowmarch" back. I started reading it myself a while back and got about 100 pages into it before I gave up. It reads way too much like a re-tread of "Memory, Sorrow, and Thorn". I was really bummed, as I loved MS&T and was looking forward to another epic series from Williams....