Krazy Kat wrote:I enjoyed reading this extract...
www.cse.dmu.ac.uk/~mward/gkc/books/heretics/ch3.html
...although, the last paragraph was a bit of a bumper-car ride. I was left undecided wether or not I was a bore or was bored. Maybe I'll read through it again, or, check out some of Kipling's poetry instead...or maybe I could just flip a coin!
I don't recall having seen you in this corner of the forum before. Good post!

Thank you!
A general problem that I have found reading Chesterton is that, being a journalist, he frequently makes references to things well-known in his time and poorly-known in ours. For me, it has resulted in a huge learning experience, as I learn about things in the 19th and 20th centuries that I knew little or nothing about. IOW, the problem was not in Chesterton - it it was more in my lack of knowledge (which has forced me to open myself to further learning). Looking up Rhodes and the Boer War might clarify a few things for you, and be instructive to boot! It was for me!
Also, his tremendous knowledge in literature has really opened up the field for me (and I say that as one who holds an MA in lit.) and made me realize its true importance - something my college education never really did. If you realize that he had a near-photographic memory of most of what he ever read, it becomes easier to understand how he could know so much. A big eye-opener for me was going back to Kipling with Chesterton's comments in mind and discovering that he was right - the big thing I had always missed was the author's worldview - what the author really believes regarding truth - the one thing never really discussed in years of college study of literature - or if discussed, then only in passing, not as a primary thing that not only influences, but actually forms works. (Wait till you begin to apply that to reading SRD - "it'll really bake your noodle"! (nod to the Matrix)
On that last paragraph - I would say that its point is in the first sentences (about making the world smaller). And this:
The difficulty comes in when we seek to know the substance of either of them.
This cosmopolitanism makes us think we know things when we really don't. One example out of the myriad is how millions of Americans sitting in their armchairs could listen to soundbites and then vote to support a war in Iraq (or anywhere else). But I digress.

I apologize for any perceived hijacking - I'd be happy to discuss the parts of that chapter relative to names, though!
"Eh? Two views? There are a dozen views about everything until you know the answer. Then there's never more than one." Bill Hingest ("That Hideous Strength" by C.S. Lewis)
"These are the days when the Christian is expected to praise every creed except his own." G.K. Chesterton