Free Will and God's Will....

Free discussion of anything human or divine ~ Philosophy, Religion and Spirituality

Moderators: Xar, Fist and Faith

Post Reply
User avatar
Avatar
Immanentizing The Eschaton
Posts: 61744
Joined: Mon Aug 02, 2004 9:17 am
Location: Johannesburg, South Africa
Has thanked: 15 times
Been thanked: 21 times

Post by Avatar »

:lol: Even inflammatory is alright to an extent Kalkin. A few disclaimers, and making sure it's not personal, and you don't have to worry too much. We're pretty easy going.

I guess so Damelon, although they think it's natural, IIRC, not down to a god. A few other religions like the idea too. Although it's a nice one, I don't believe it any more than I believe in any other religious explanation really. I'm more of a "you live, then you die, and that's it" kinda person. It's just the principle I was illustrating.

If there really is a plan, it's rigged. ;)

--A
Top
User avatar
aliantha
blueberries on steroids
Posts: 17865
Joined: Tue Mar 05, 2002 7:50 pm
Location: NOT opening up a restaurant in Santa Fe

Post by aliantha »

Avatar wrote:If there really is a plan, it's rigged. ;)

--A
:LOLS:
Image
Image

EZ Board Survivor

"Dreaming isn't good for you unless you do the things it tells you to." -- Three Dog Night (via the GI)

https://www.hearth-myth.com/
Top
User avatar
Nathan
The Gap Into Spam
Posts: 2448
Joined: Wed Jun 23, 2004 7:14 pm
Location: Nottingham

Post by Nathan »

Vraith wrote:False Choice
You seem to be arguing that when you are unable to do something you want to, you are being deprived of your free will. I don't believe this is the case.

What if I wanted to fly under my own power? I can't do it, it's impossible. Have I lost my free will? No I haven't, because it's the wanting part which is important.

Free will means that you get to want (or try to do) whatever you like, not that you get to do whatever you like, otherwise everyone would be able to do everything.

In your example of a choice between you or your brother being killed, you are free to work towards any outcome you like. The man with the gun is setting the rules, though, and you're at a disadvantage. Doesn't make you any less free to try to escape, you'll just have to take whatever consequences occur as a result of the rules of the situation.

The same holds true for any example you could give. You're always able to want or try absolutely anything. It's achieving your goals where the difficulty lies. Whether you succeed or fail at whatever you try, your free will has already been exercised.
[spoiler]If you change the font to white within spoiler tags does it break them?[/spoiler]
Top
User avatar
Avatar
Immanentizing The Eschaton
Posts: 61744
Joined: Mon Aug 02, 2004 9:17 am
Location: Johannesburg, South Africa
Has thanked: 15 times
Been thanked: 21 times

Post by Avatar »

Nathan?!? :lol: Welcome back.

And good post.

--A
Top
User avatar
Orlion
The Gap Into Spam
Posts: 6666
Joined: Sun Aug 26, 2007 12:30 am
Location: Getting there...
Been thanked: 1 time

Post by Orlion »

Nathan wrote:
In your example of a choice between you or your brother being killed, you are free to work towards any outcome you like. The man with the gun is setting the rules, though, and you're at a disadvantage. Doesn't make you any less free to try to escape, you'll just have to take whatever consequences occur as a result of the rules of the situation.

The same holds true for any example you could give. You're always able to want or try absolutely anything. It's achieving your goals where the difficulty lies. Whether you succeed or fail at whatever you try, your free will has already been exercised.
But there in lies the problem, for me. Free Will, or even just will, is more synomous to liberty for me then it is with agency. The fact that your will is that you and your brother live would show in this example that your will is being overcome by the man with the gun. Fine, you can still choose, but you can not enact your will, that ability has been taken from you.
'Tis dream to think that Reason can
Govern the reasoning creature, man.
- Herman Melville

I am Lazarus, come from the dead,
Come back to tell you all, I shall tell you all!

"All creation is a huge, ornate, imaginary, and unintended fiction; if it could be deciphered it would yield a single shocking word."
-John Crowley
Top
User avatar
Avatar
Immanentizing The Eschaton
Posts: 61744
Joined: Mon Aug 02, 2004 9:17 am
Location: Johannesburg, South Africa
Has thanked: 15 times
Been thanked: 21 times

Post by Avatar »

I agree with Nate. It's not the succeeding that matters. It's the trying. Pretty sure SRD said somthing very similar.

If it was only success that proved free will, then losing a game would be having your freedom to win taken from you.

In this scenario, you are free to try and escape, or turn the tables on your attacker, or do nothing. He is free to try and stop you.

--A
Top
User avatar
hierachy
Lord
Posts: 4813
Joined: Tue Sep 16, 2003 10:20 pm

Post by hierachy »

So I could write some long post, but I'd rather say it with a picture.

Image
Top
User avatar
Nathan
The Gap Into Spam
Posts: 2448
Joined: Wed Jun 23, 2004 7:14 pm
Location: Nottingham

Post by Nathan »

Orlion wrote:fact that your will is that you and your brother live would show in this example that your will is being overcome by the man with the gun.
If you define free will as "Being able to acheive everything you try" then nobody has free will. There is nobody who has ever existed who has been able to succeed at everything he attempted.

That must mean either that free will doesn't exist, or that you'll have to tone down your definition of free will to a more realistic one.
[spoiler]If you change the font to white within spoiler tags does it break them?[/spoiler]
Top
User avatar
ur-bane
The Gap Into Spam
Posts: 3496
Joined: Tue Jun 29, 2004 10:35 am
Location: United States of Andelain

Post by ur-bane »

Avatar wrote:I agree with Nate. It's not the succeeding that matters. It's the trying. Pretty sure SRD said somthing very similar.

If it was only success that proved free will, then losing a game would be having your freedom to win taken from you.

In this scenario, you are free to try and escape, or turn the tables on your attacker, or do nothing. He is free to try and stop you.

--A
I am going to take that a step further and say it's not only the trying, but the will---or desire-- to try in the first place.
I have to agree with Orlion in that action/ability is a seperate entity from will.

"Free will," after what I have read, seems to me to encompass too many variables to allow a definition to be written concretely, or to determine with any semblance of certainty that it truly exists at all.
Image

Nearly all men can stand adversity, but if you want
to test a man's character, give him power.
--Abraham Lincoln

Excerpt from Animal Songs Never Written
"Hey, dad," croaked the vulture, "what are you eating?"
"Carrion, my wayward son."
"Will there be pieces when you are done?"
Top
User avatar
Avatar
Immanentizing The Eschaton
Posts: 61744
Joined: Mon Aug 02, 2004 9:17 am
Location: Johannesburg, South Africa
Has thanked: 15 times
Been thanked: 21 times

Post by Avatar »

Hmmm. Well, we are certainly free to want anything we like... :D

(Good to see you around.)

--A
Top
User avatar
ur-bane
The Gap Into Spam
Posts: 3496
Joined: Tue Jun 29, 2004 10:35 am
Location: United States of Andelain

Post by ur-bane »

Absolutely true, Av. Which is why "free will" can neither solely be defined by desire, nor can desire be taken out of the definition.
Image

Nearly all men can stand adversity, but if you want
to test a man's character, give him power.
--Abraham Lincoln

Excerpt from Animal Songs Never Written
"Hey, dad," croaked the vulture, "what are you eating?"
"Carrion, my wayward son."
"Will there be pieces when you are done?"
Top
Post Reply

Return to “The Close”