Okay I've seen a few posts now about people complaining about things that have taken place in the book. The most recent one was how TC handles his wife and his son.
First his son:
TC has just spent how many years as the guardian of the arch of time? He's recently made human, encounters his son, and has bearly a thing to say to him. Can't say that I am surprised. As the arch of time he was privy to everything that has happened. He knows what has gone before and is aware of what his son has done and is doing (even if he is having problems with memory since being reincarnated as human). TC gave his life in defense of the land and his son is attempting to destroy it. I wouldn't have much to say to my son given the same situation. The reason I say this is that you can tell whether someone is repentent for their actions and therefore open to changing their ways. Roger impersonated TC for the purposes of trying to destroy the world in FR. That's hardly someone who is open for the possibility to change and be redeemed.
His wife:
While TC does have a great deal of devotion to Joan, deliverance and redemption are two different things. While he may (haven't read AATE yet still waiting for my copy) have had the opportunity and option to not kill Joan, look at what Joan was bring forced to do with the power that was given to her. She's broken but not in the same way that TC was broken when he came to the land the first time. Her damage is one that can't be fixed with hurtloam and spending time with giants telling stories. As long as Joan, who had been being held captive in the land and tortured causing the casures lived she is a threat. Even if somehow she was restored she was damaged and by killing her he set her free from the pain that she was causing and suffering.
TC and family
Book 3 of the Last Chronicles of Thomas Covenant
Moderators: dlbpharmd, High Lord Tolkien
-
- Servant of the Land
- Posts: 5
- Joined: Thu Oct 21, 2010 4:00 pm
- Location: Denver, CO
Shadowslance
Return to “Against All Things Ending”
Jump to
- The Watch
- ↳ Announcements + Suggestions + Q&A + Help
- ↳ The Summonsing
- The Waymeet
- ↳ General Discussion Forum
- ↳ General Fantasy/Sci-Fi Discussion
- ↳ General Literature Discussion
- ↳ The Library
- ↳ J.K. Rowling Forum
- ↳ J.R.R. Tolkien Forum
- ↳ Stephen King Forum
- ↳ Star Wars and Star Trek Forum
- ↳ George R. R. Martin Forum
- ↳ Steven Erikson Forum
- ↳ Andelain
- ↳ The Galley
- ↳ Sports
- ↳ Vespers
- ↳ PC & Console Games
- ↳ dANdeLION's Comics Cave
- ↳ TV Shows
- ↳ Flicks
- ↳ Forum Games
- ↳ In Pursuit of Mallory
- ↳ Scions Of Eiran
- ↳ Gravin Threndor
- Stephen R. Donaldson Forums
- ↳ The First and Second Chronicles of Thomas Covenant
- ↳ The Last Chronicles of Thomas Covenant
- ↳ The Runes of the Earth
- ↳ Fatal Revenant
- ↳ Against All Things Ending
- ↳ The Last Dark
- ↳ The Entire Chronicles
- ↳ The Gap Series
- ↳ Mordant's Need
- ↳ The Great God's War
- ↳ Seventh Decimate
- ↳ The War Within
- ↳ The Killing God
- ↳ General SRD Discussion and Other Works
- ↳ The Chronicles Art Gallery
- ↳ Group Readings
- ↳ Dissecting The Land
- ↳ 1st Chronicles
- ↳ 2nd Chronicles
- ↳ Last Chronicles
- ↳ Ancillary Documentation
- ↳ Casting the Augury
- Revelstone
- ↳ Governing Council for Earth and Space
- ↳ The Close
- ↳ The Loresraat
- ↳ Doriendor Corishev
- ↳ The Hall of Gifts
- ↳ Kevin's Watch Anthology Forum
- Kevin's Watch
- ↳ Pantheon
- ↳ GM's Dungeon
- ↳ Temp
- ↳ The Watchy Awards Forum
- ↳ Coercri
- ↳ Haven Farm
- ↳ The Archive
- ↳ Purgatory
- ↳ Demon: The Fallen
- ↳ Borderlands
- ↳ Prophets
- ↳ Zombie Apocalypse
- ↳ Heart of God
- ↳ Empires
- ↳ Nationstates
- ↳ Acropolis
- ↳ D&D-Darkwood
- ↳ Inferno
- ↳ Vampire: Dark Ages
- ↳ Valley of Eden
- ↳ D&D Dark Hope
- ↳ D&D Weretiger's Curse
- ↳ Vampire: Requiem
- ↳ Valley of Blood
- ↳ Aesir & Vanir
- ↳ Rogue Trader
- ↳ Phoenix Prime
- ↳ Acropolis 1.0
- ↳ Balance of Power
- ↳ Warhammer
- ↳ Compendium Galactica
- ↳ Lovecraftian Conversion
- ↳ Heart of God: The Outsiders