When Kevin contronted the Despiser, the Haruchai did not take part. Twice before had Covenant contronted Lord Foul, but the Haruchai did not take part. Only now, in these Last Chronicles, will they will accompany the Timewarden to the final showdown. It is as if the Haruchai, in their redemption, have finally been permitted to partake of salvation.
These are the Last Chronicles for me as well. I have led eight chapter dissections previously, but after this one, I will never lead another. Finality weighs upon me as I write. But it is an appropriate mood for this chapter. We are in Mount Thunder, a confrontation with Lord Foul looms near, and the end of all things pervades each sentence we read. As readers, we hope some sort of salvation lies ahead.
The last chapter ended with that cliff-hanger.In [i]The Last Dark[/i] was wrote:For the first time, Linden saw open astonishment on the impassive face of a Haruchai.
The Masters are here in Mount Thunder. And they seem as surprised to see Covenant as Covenant is to see them.
They have arrived just in time to help the company escape the Cavewights.
Two hundered Haruchai have come. Five-score are considered "a veritable army in their sight". So: two armies worth of Haruchai are somewhere within Mount Thunder. But only four individuals have found the company so far: Canrik, Dast, Ulman, and Ard.
It is enough. Covenant has a moment of vertigo, as the plight of his friends urges the wild magic toward utterance. But they are saved with the help of their new allies, and his mental balance is restored.
But Canrik insists that there are questions that need answering. They were unaware that Covenant had returned to life. And he glares at Linden as if she is a crime. The Masters have been given lies.
Another Giant has died in combat. Bluff Stoutgirth grieves for Hurl, his crewmate. There is no time for caamora, which is as grevious a blow to the Anchormaster as the death itself. And so Hurl is hurled into the river; may his soul find the sea. Among the Giants, five Swordmainnir have died, and four sailors, and Lostson Longwrath. Five Swordmainnir and eight sailors remain.
Their sacrifice weighs on Covenant.
Linden. Jeremiah. Love. Family.In [i]The Last Dark[/i] was wrote:Fortunately he was not alone. In the Land, he had seldom been alone; but this time he had been given more than companionship and aid.
Stave. Branl. Giants. And Haruchai.
Covenant is not the man he was before he died. He understands now, more than ever, this his personal journey is not a journey made alone. He may finally confront the Despiser, but he has been blessed with those without whom it would not be possible. This has been true since the beginning, but now Covenant is almost at peace with this, he accepts it more readily, as if he understands that his achievements and his companions are not two disparate things, but two sides of one thing, integral to each other.In [i]The Last Dark[/i] was wrote:He did not know how to bear such abundance. He had spent decades in one world and millennia in another learning how to stand alone.
The company climbs away from the ledge where they were ambushed. Then through the tunnels of the Cavewights. Other Haruchai join them as they travel. Kiril Threndor seems near.In [i]The Last Dark[/i] was wrote:“It isn’t all bad,” he said roughly. “At least we’re still together. Some of us made it.”
He meant, I love you, Linden Avery.
Her hug seemed to say that she understood.
Soon they reach a small cavern, chosen by the Masters as the place where questions will be answered. Yet more Haruchai arrive, and they also bring Bhapa and Pahni with them, who stand at the core of the Masters' ire. If the Masters are not answered, they may very well prevent Covenant from reaching Kiril Threndor, Linden from the task which she has chosen. And they're pretty mad.
Bhapa and Pahni have changed since we have last seen them. Bhapa proclaims, "The blame of the outcome is mine and no others." And Pahni replies, "He has become my manethrall." Somewhere during their confrontation with the Masters in Revelstone, they have matured, grown: come into their own.
Handir, by right of years and attainment the Voice of the Masters, arrives.
Bhapa, to Handir's chagrin, relates the cause of the Masters' "open astonishment". It seems he had never mentioned to them that Thomas Covenant was returned to life. He had played up Linden's culpability in the matter of the Worm, had described her as a reckless mother heedless of all but her son's safety. The Masters came to the Wightwarrens to punish Linden for her crimes.
And so Bhapa misdirected the Masters for two reasons. First, to motivate them into actions which they might have otherwise chosen to forgo. Secondly, to shame them for their judgemental stance in service to the Land.In [i]The Last Dark[/i] was wrote:“Bhapa of the Ramen, it is not in the nature of your people to scheme and mislead. Why have you betrayed their legacy? Why have you concealed necessary truths?”
“It was for this,” he told Handir in a tone of throttled fury. “That you might here encounter the truth of the Ringthane, the Chosen, Linden Avery — encounter it and know shame.”
“Linden Avery, Chosen, Ringthane, I am offended to the marrow of my bones that these sleepless ones have dared to think ill of you. They have named themselves the Masters of the Land, but they do not serve. True service submits itself to the cause which it serves, deeming that cause holy. This the Ramen comprehend. True service does not judge the deeds which are asked of it. It does not consent to this and refuse that, according to the dictates of its own pride. It gives of itself because the cause which it serves is worthy.
“That is my justification. I did not mislead the Masters for the Land’s hurt, or for their own. I merely” — he spat the word — “encouraged them in their judgments and pride, praying that they would ride forth in wrath to confront Desecration. Thereby I hoped to impose upon them a confrontation with their own folly.”
This shame plays its part in the redemption of the Haruchai. For they must see first that they have been wrong, before they can see a new path.
The Masters have been misguided. As we learned in an earlier chapter, they do not choose to know themselves by what they care for, but instead by what they accomplish. Confronted by a choice between the two, the Masters considered their reputations more important than the Land they served. This led inevitably to their antagonism towards Linden, who required their service at the expense of their vanity. Here, now, they can see that they have chosen wrongly.
Branl remains. His promise to instruct his people remains. But, now, his people might feel inclinded to accept it.In [i]The Last Dark[/i] was wrote:Bhapa had brought the Masters to a crisis of rectitude, a challenge which would search their definition of themselves to its core.
[There is a more detailed analysis of the Masters' shame in a reply below.]
That the Masters are in Mount Thunder, in large numbers, atests to Bhapa's correct judgement. That the Ranyhyn consented to carry them here, but not another ten score who had set out to Melenkurion Skyweir in order to defy the Worm, atests to the Ranyhyn sharing his judgement.
We don't see anything like Handir putting his face in his palm, or admitting to any errors, or asking for any forgiveness. What he does is complain about Covenants plan to go to Kiril Threndor. It is implied that all of the Haruchai he commands will accompany Covenant regardless. Implied in this implication is that he has been swayed by what Bhapa has said. And within the implication within that implication, is the implication that the Haruchai have been changed a little bit more.
Covenant always puts things into perspective, doesn't he?In [i]The Last Dark[/i] was wrote:“If we must be shamed, we will bear it. We are Haruchai. Yet it is cruel — is it not? — to insist upon our service in the name of folly. In the name of futility, ur-Lord. In the name of waste.”
Covenant grinned at him fiercely. “You tell me. Which would you rather do? Die here fighting Cavewights? Take the chance that something good might happen? Or be swept out of existence while you stand around complaining about waste?”
The Voice of the Masters paused for only a moment. Then he said without inflection, “We will fight.”