Page 2 of 3
Posted: Wed Oct 21, 2009 12:50 pm
by wayfriend
Theomachy is actually a word in the dictionary. You may want to look it up. And then talk about it in the Fatal Revenant forum. Hint. Hint.
Posted: Wed Oct 21, 2009 6:53 pm
by Blackhawk
Look what happens to a spoiler when you use Emoticons in it.

Are your guys Spoilers really spoilers?

I want to read them but I dont want to know more about FR before i Read it.. I already found out about some less than happy Giant.


Posted: Wed Oct 21, 2009 7:33 pm
by Savor Dam
Blackhawk, yes, they are spoilers for the most part. Until you choose to read FR, shun them!
Posted: Wed Oct 21, 2009 8:36 pm
by Vader
This is not a spoiler:
TC's a leper. Don't touch him. HELLFIRE.
Posted: Wed Oct 21, 2009 9:41 pm
by Relayer
Agreed with SG and Vader's comments.
Posted: Thu Oct 22, 2009 3:29 am
by SGuilfoyle1966
What was the question again?
Posted: Thu Oct 22, 2009 3:55 pm
by peter
SGuilfoyle1966 wrote:What was the question again?
Something about how was the first Staff of Law cut from the One Tree when Covenant had such a job trying to secure the second.
Posted: Thu Dec 17, 2009 9:53 am
by Krazy Kat
The following applies only to those who don't use real trees.
How To Make A Staff Of Law
(and commit the Ritual of Desecration at the same time)
On the twelfth day of Christmas when it's time to put away the tree for another year, don't just stop when you've removed all the tinsle and the fairy lights. Remove all the wiry branches too. Then strip away the staples and bits of sellotape and foil to reveal...yes folks! The Staff of Law - and also, the desecrated remains of your ex-Christmas Tree.
This do-it-yourself handy tip was brought to you by VAIN & LAZY SHORTCUTS LTD.
MERRY CHRISTMAS
Posted: Thu Dec 17, 2009 4:56 pm
by Relayer
LOL. that sounds much better than dragging the thing down to the creek behind the house.
BTW, nice avatar!

Posted: Thu Dec 17, 2009 9:15 pm
by soft one
Look... here's how he got it.
Christmas was over, and Berek was sitting with his parents looking at all the stuff he had received. His brother was asleep on the floor. The Old Man asked him if he got everything he wanted for Christmas. Berek shrugged his shoulders and said, "I guess."
The Old Man suddenly looked up and said, "What's that?" Berek asked, "Where?" "Right there, in the corner... it looks like the Creator put another present there.
Berek got up and slowly pulled an oddly shaped present from behind the desk. He gingerly opened it... it was what he always wanted! A branch from the One Tree!
The Old Man looked at Berek's mom and said, "I had one when I was 8 years old." Berek turned and asked his mom, "Can I make a Staff of Law from it?" Mom said, "Oh, alright. Just use it outside and DON'T SHOOT YOUR EYE OUT!"
Posted: Thu Dec 17, 2009 9:28 pm
by wayfriend
Wasn't that right after Berek had to wear the cute wanyhim pajamas, the ones with the gaping nostrils on the feet?
Posted: Fri Dec 18, 2009 5:13 am
by Krazy Kat
Relayer wrote:BTW, nice avatar!

I like the Olias of Sunhillow emblem but I'm not to keen on it as an avatar.
So it's back to the previous one for the time being!
BTW, maybe the post I did should have made in a
lomillialor thread...ah, what the hey!
Posted: Fri Dec 18, 2009 4:31 pm
by Relayer
Yea, it's a great symbol. Of course, being Relayer I'm somewhat biased

Posted: Fri Dec 18, 2009 5:23 pm
by Blackhawk
soft one wrote:Look... here's how he got it.
Christmas was over, and Berek was sitting with his parents looking at all the stuff he had received. His brother was asleep on the floor. The Old Man asked him if he got everything he wanted for Christmas. Berek shrugged his shoulders and said, "I guess."
The Old Man suddenly looked up and said, "What's that?" Berek asked, "Where?" "Right there, in the corner... it looks like the Creator put another present there.
Berek got up and slowly pulled an oddly shaped present from behind the desk. He gingerly opened it... it was what he always wanted! A branch from the One Tree!
The Old Man looked at Berek's mom and said, "I had one when I was 8 years old." Berek turned and asked his mom, "Can I make a Staff of Law from it?" Mom said, "Oh, alright. Just use it outside and DON'T SHOOT YOUR EYE OUT!"
Very nice... LOL!!!!
wayfriend wrote:
Wasn't that right after Berek had to wear the cute wanyhim pajamas, the ones with the gaping nostrils on the feet?
OK... now my side is hurting...

Posted: Wed Dec 23, 2009 3:35 pm
by jackgiantkiller
[spoilerThere was a guardian to the one tree when Berek approched it! Im sure the insequent who accompnies berek is stated as defeating a Elhomin who guarded the tree, or have I got that mixed up with somthing I made up in my own headspoiler]
Posted: Thu Dec 24, 2009 7:53 am
by Thorhammerhand
Yes, there was a guardian. No, you did not make it up. Yes, SRD acknowledged that he made a mistake in his writing (Gradual Interview Feb 2008)
Posted: Sun Feb 07, 2010 6:27 am
by balon!
Was there a guardian posted?
I feel like the first thread I started here was on this exact subject...
And how the hell did Berek manage to get to the Isle in the first place, when Damelon was the first Lord to meet the Giants? (and they were lost anyway)
Posted: Sun Feb 07, 2010 4:34 pm
by High Lord Tolkien
balon! wrote:
And how the hell did Berek manage to get to the Isle in the first place, when Damelon was the first Lord to meet the Giants? (and they were lost anyway)
Other races built boats besides Giants.
But it was hinted by Findail (I think) that the One Tree is not always in the same place.
At the Time of Berek it might have been Land-bound, perhaps in the Northern or Southern Climbs?
Posted: Sun Feb 07, 2010 8:16 pm
by balon!
High Lord Tolkien wrote:Other races built boats besides Giants.
But it was hinted by Findail (I think) that the One Tree is not always in the same place.
At the Time of Berek it might have been Land-bound, perhaps in the Northern or Southern Climbs?
Interesting idea...
Being in the Land would explain the lack of Giantish aid.
Posted: Thu Apr 22, 2010 9:46 pm
by Krazy Kat
It's possible this information about Berek's quest is in there somewhere, rooted in paradox and symbolism, but I like to think it's always been kept out of the Chronicles deliberately and that one day Stephen Donaldson might publish this as a standalone book - The Legend of Berek Halfhand.
And maybe even as part of another tril with the Bagoon and Thelma story.
Isn't it great when you first seen a brand new SRD book in the bookshop
And of course, Linden Avery would have to play a part -

-
(i've been feeling a bit THOOLAHy this week)
EDIT: I was thinking about how Berek's story is similair to Troy's. Both were chased near to death. Wildwood could play a part in both tales.
Pity the tapestry in the Tower didn't reveal more info.
Covenant was forced to summon the Fire Lions as Berek had.
If the Fire Lions responded only to the Staff of Law, did Berek have it when he tapped into the Earthpower?
Which would lead back to Wildwood and the One Tree.