Page 2 of 2
Posted: Wed Jan 12, 2011 7:00 pm
by ur-Timewarden
Horrim Carabal wrote:Zarathustra wrote:Roger could have threatened to punch Linden in her vagina
I predict this will happen in TLD.
I was just about to add this to my list of "Official Predictions", when I realized that the moment the attempt was made, Stave would jump in front and take one for the team. I think he has to lose a body part a book. Let's just say that after taking a skurj-handed punch to the nether regions, he won't be making any more Galts.

Posted: Thu Jan 13, 2011 11:55 pm
by Horrim Carabal
ninjaboy wrote:I honestly was pretty disappointed with the 'sucker' line..
It is ugly, and it's juvenile.. It's what a 15-yr old might have said.
And it's at odds with the cold, callous, calculating Roger we saw at the beginning of ROTE, or even the 'disguised' or 'revealed' Roger in FR.
The guy's got an insane Elohim's amputated hand grafted to the end of his arm. That's gotta change a person a bit.
I love the line, personally.
ur-Timewarden wrote:Horrim Carabal wrote:Zarathustra wrote:Roger could have threatened to punch Linden in her vagina
I predict this will happen in TLD.
I was just about to add this to my list of "Official Predictions", when I realized that the moment the attempt was made, Stave would jump in front and take one for the team. I think he has to lose a body part a book. Let's just say that after taking a skurj-handed punch to the nether regions, he won't be making any more Galts.


Analysis like that is why I come to the Watch!

Posted: Sun Jan 23, 2011 3:13 am
by ninjaboy
Just reading AATE again, and the Harrow really is growing on me, you know? Especially when they are trying to get through that portal..
Not such a bad character after all..
Posted: Sun Jan 23, 2011 5:42 am
by thewormoftheworld'send
ninjaboy wrote:Just reading AATE again, and the Harrow really is growing on me, you know? Especially when they are trying to get through that portal..
Not such a bad character after all..
Do you mean not bad as in not evil?
Disappointed
Posted: Sun Jan 23, 2011 8:21 pm
by SkurjMaster
I was disappointed with the character of the Harrow. I thought he would be a more meaningful character to the ending of the series. He has more potential depth as a character than what was utilized.
Posted: Sun Jan 23, 2011 10:04 pm
by Lord Zombiac
Hey dude, I have bad news for you: this story isn't real. What you're saying is interesting factually but, in reality, nobody living in a small town American community is going to contract leprosy anyway. The entire leprosy premise of the Chrons is wayyyy out in left field.
In fact, most cases of leprosy in the US are in Rural Texas and Louisiana.
I don't know if there's a connection, but the armadillo is the only animal besides man that can contract leprosy.
Re: Disappointed
Posted: Sun Jan 23, 2011 10:05 pm
by Lord Zombiac
SkurjMaster wrote:I was disappointed with the character of the Harrow. I thought he would be a more meaningful character to the ending of the series. He has more potential depth as a character than what was utilized.
I figured he would die fairly soon after taking the staff of law and the white gold. That was the only way that stuff could get back in Linden's hands where it belonged.
Re: Disappointed
Posted: Mon Jan 24, 2011 3:52 am
by ninjaboy
Lord Zombiac wrote:SkurjMaster wrote:I was disappointed with the character of the Harrow. I thought he would be a more meaningful character to the ending of the series. He has more potential depth as a character than what was utilized.
I figured he would die fairly soon after taking the staff of law and the white gold. That was the only way that stuff could get back in Linden's hands where it belonged.
That does make sense, I gotta say.. And it's a lot more bearable than Linden being without her 'powers' and having many chapters of her perspective just whining about how she's powerless..
Re: Disappointed
Posted: Mon Jan 24, 2011 3:53 am
by thewormoftheworld'send
Lord Zombiac wrote:SkurjMaster wrote:I was disappointed with the character of the Harrow. I thought he would be a more meaningful character to the ending of the series. He has more potential depth as a character than what was utilized.
I figured he would die fairly soon after taking the staff of law and the white gold. That was the only way that stuff could get back in Linden's hands where it belonged.
What else did you predict about AATE?
Posted: Mon Jan 24, 2011 3:58 am
by ninjaboy
TheWormoftheWorld'sEnd wrote:ninjaboy wrote:Just reading AATE again, and the Harrow really is growing on me, you know? Especially when they are trying to get through that portal..
Not such a bad character after all..
Do you mean not bad as in not evil?
Well I meant not bad as in.. Interesting.. With depth, with a wide range of emotions, and with grand desires that would have been fun and involving to explore.. A good charcter, basically.
But as him being good / evil.. That's what makes him so interesting. We don't know. He is rude, uncaring, and his methods of achieving his goals are dishonourable.. But if his goals truly are what he stated, than how can he be bad?
The Harrow
Posted: Mon Jan 24, 2011 6:46 am
by SleeplessOne
I agree Ninjaboy, I thought the Harrow was a great character and was disappointed to lose him relatively early on in the story ..
Re: The Harrow
Posted: Mon Jan 24, 2011 7:13 am
by Lord Zombiac
SleeplessOne wrote:I agree Ninjaboy, I thought the Harrow was a great character and was disappointed to lose him relatively early on in the story ..
Certainly one of the most vividly described, but a very dark and dangerous character who needed to be eliminated!
He ATE the demondim?
He TRIED to eat Linden?
His only redeeming quality was his plan to use Jeremiah to trap the worm.
Re: The Harrow
Posted: Mon Jan 24, 2011 3:05 pm
by thewormoftheworld'send
Lord Zombiac wrote:SleeplessOne wrote:I agree Ninjaboy, I thought the Harrow was a great character and was disappointed to lose him relatively early on in the story ..
Certainly one of the most vividly described, but a very dark and dangerous character who needed to be eliminated!
He ATE the demondim?
He TRIED to eat Linden?
His only redeeming quality was his plan to use Jeremiah to trap the worm.
The Demondim were undone through the plucking of that one string binding them to reality. That was exactly the same technique Linden used on the Door to where the Viles used to hang out.
Posted: Wed Apr 27, 2011 12:42 pm
by jonnyredleader
I did double take when i read suck-ER, after hearing apotheosis, rectitude and puissance throughout i thought someone had snuck in at the publishers and thought it would be funny!

Posted: Thu Apr 28, 2011 2:55 pm
by Hashi Lebwohl
No, it is simply that Roger is unimaginative and has a pathetic excuse for a vocabulary.
Posted: Tue May 17, 2011 5:12 pm
by Seeker of Truth
I believe that the Harrow had been killed off too early - after re-reading AATE again (as one does

) the character of the Harrow began to grow on me.
Here is a character that understands how to use both the white gold & the staff - not afraid to take on Demondim etc...totally without morals.... my kinda guy!
Whilst his passing was spectatcular...(molten fist thru chest) I hope he comes back to haunt Roger for saying SUCK-errr ..

Posted: Sat May 21, 2011 3:17 am
by RFlowers
Lord Zombiac wrote:Hey dude, I have bad news for you: this story isn't real. What you're saying is interesting factually but, in reality, nobody living in a small town American community is going to contract leprosy anyway. The entire leprosy premise of the Chrons is wayyyy out in left field.
In fact, most cases of leprosy in the US are in Rural Texas and Louisiana.
I don't know if there's a connection, but the armadillo is the only animal besides man that can contract leprosy.
I read an article recently that they discovered leprosy can jump from the armadillo to humans, and that explains many of previously unaccountable infections.
Posted: Wed Jun 15, 2011 11:09 pm
by bossk
TheWormoftheWorld'sEnd wrote:Ur Dead wrote:What did you expect from Roger...
A quote from Hamlet or King Lear?
Goes to show that Roger used words that was familair to him.
Also it shows that he didn't read his fathers books..
or anybody else for that fact.
Apparently he said something that doesn't belong in a fantasy novel. He spent most of FR saying similar things (f-bombs and such), so I wasn't particularly surprised at this one.
Definitely the way I saw it. Fit perfectly with the jarring way he acted and spoke while impersonating TC. I mean, he's the ultimate douchebag in a Land where everyone's so earnestly good or evil. This guy's just a schmuck with a white whine and Kastenessen's Hulk Hand.
Posted: Sun Jun 26, 2011 4:03 am
by Ur Dead
Roger never read any of SRD books.
So sucker is the right word.