Page 5 of 7
Posted: Sun Sep 17, 2006 2:17 am
by Tulizar
A Gunslinger wrote:
Anything by ABC, OMD, Spandau Ballet, The Human League, Animotion, and any other '80s band that didn't feature a guitarist.
That is so damn funny and true that I am still a-laffin'! Good one buddy!
Oh, So I guess you guys don't want those Pet Shop Boys cds I burned for you?!!
Posted: Sun Sep 17, 2006 3:57 pm
by Trapper
A Gunslinger. Feel free to see Tom Petty as an icon.
I just don't agree.
And I found that song encapsulated what I don't like about him.
onewyteduck:
It's not off-topic if that is part of the reason I personally dislike the song...
You're perfectly free to say what you like about Springsteen and the others you mentioned. I happen to feel that way about Petty.
Posted: Sun Sep 17, 2006 4:38 pm
by lucimay
onewyteduck wrote:Trapper439 wrote:I loathe Tom Petty.
Especially that egocentric and opportunistic "We need peace in LA" song he released within about 12 hours after the Rodney King riots.
Thanks for rushing straight to the studio/Batcave and fixing that situation, Tom. Now if you could just write a song about Cold Fusion, please...
And then shut up.
I'm curious. I've heard this criticism before. And there have been some others.....Springsteen's The Rising, Elton John's remake of Candle In The Wind after the Princess Di affair.......(just to mention a few). Why is it no one ever said the same thing about Neil Young and Ohio?
oooh...i'm so excited...something to moderate in Vespers!!
first of all..that was an hilarious post about Petty Trap!
secondly, i THINK, when she stuck the little off topic emo in her post, Duck was warning us that she was going to go off topic with her comment and question, not that YOU were off topic.
thirdly, i also think the reason nobody said that about Young's Ohio is because of the times, the zeitgeist of that period. it was considered a protest song. same with Nash's Chicago, which protests the trial of the Chicago 7. those two songs are in a different category entirely. don't you think?
Posted: Sun Sep 17, 2006 5:25 pm
by onewyteduck
Lucimay wrote:onewyteduck wrote:Trapper439 wrote:I loathe Tom Petty.
Especially that egocentric and opportunistic "We need peace in LA" song he released within about 12 hours after the Rodney King riots.
Thanks for rushing straight to the studio/Batcave and fixing that situation, Tom. Now if you could just write a song about Cold Fusion, please...
And then shut up.
I'm curious. I've heard this criticism before. And there have been some others.....Springsteen's The Rising, Elton John's remake of Candle In The Wind after the Princess Di affair.......(just to mention a few). Why is it no one ever said the same thing about Neil Young and Ohio?
oooh...i'm so excited...something to moderate in Vespers!!
first of all..that was an hilarious post about Petty Trap!
secondly, i THINK, when she stuck the little off topic emo in her post, Duck was warning us that she was going to go off topic with her comment and question, not that YOU were off topic.
thirdly, i also think the reason nobody said that about Young's Ohio is because of the times, the zeitgeist of that period. it was considered a protest song. same with Nash's Chicago, which protests the trial of the Chicago 7. those two songs are in a different category entirely. don't you think?

Lucimay, I am delighted to have presented you with an opportunity to exercise your Godly powers!

And, yes, I was marking
my comment as off-topic.
Trapper, I didn't intend to contradict or criticize you. It's nothing more or less than a simple curiosity point. I can't say one way or the other as I live in a radio wasteland and don't think I have ever even heard the song!
Gunslinger wrote:
Ahem... all of the proceeds of the peace in LA song went to rebuilding the affected neighborhood(s). Petty is an ICON, man! Ranked right up there with Springsteen, et.al.
As for opportunism... anyone who knows anything about Springsteen knows that he doesn't give a crap about $$ any more. He does what he does out of artistic expression and to fufill his own moral compass. The songthe Rising is perhaps one of the great somgs about death and dying this side of "Knocking on Heave'ns door"!
I agree with you on Springsteen. And, a couple of other songs off the album, You're Missing and Into The Fire make me want to cry.
And for the record, I'm not inclined to accuse any of them of being opportunistic! So, peace, rock-on and Duck out!
Posted: Sun Sep 17, 2006 6:03 pm
by Trapper
Thanks for the moderation Lucimay.
A Gunslinger did have a good point that I hadn't previously appreciated about Petty's charitable intentions. And I didn't mean to criticize you either onewyteduck.
It's ALL good...

Posted: Sun Sep 17, 2006 8:36 pm
by CovenantJr
Tulizar wrote:A Gunslinger wrote:
Anything by ABC, OMD, Spandau Ballet, The Human League, Animotion, and any other '80s band that didn't feature a guitarist.
That is so damn funny and true that I am still a-laffin'! Good one buddy!
Oh, So I guess you guys don't want those Pet Shop Boys cds I burned for you?!!
I'll have them...
Posted: Sun Sep 17, 2006 11:08 pm
by Cail
Other than "West End Girls" I never cared for them, though their cover of "Go West" was hysterical.
"Saturday in the Park" by Chicago. Oh man that song sucks.
Posted: Sun Sep 17, 2006 11:20 pm
by lucimay
Cail wrote:"Saturday in the Park" by Chicago. Oh man that song sucks.
nuh uh. does not.

Posted: Mon Sep 18, 2006 1:00 am
by Loredoctor
CovenantJr wrote:James Blunt. Anyone who's heard of him knows which song I mean.
Anything by James Blunt. He's boring.
Posted: Mon Sep 18, 2006 3:25 am
by sgt.null
add John Mayer to the dull list...
Posted: Mon Sep 18, 2006 4:22 am
by lucimay
Trapper439 wrote:Thanks for the moderation Lucimay.
A Gunslinger did have a good point that I hadn't previously appreciated about Petty's charitable intentions. And I didn't mean to criticize you either onewyteduck.
It's ALL good...

yer welcome.

how was my Avatar imitation, Tankers?

Posted: Mon Sep 18, 2006 4:36 am
by Loredoctor
sgtnull wrote:add John Mayer to the dull list...
Done.

Posted: Mon Sep 18, 2006 5:00 am
by onewyteduck
Lucimay wrote:Trapper439 wrote:Thanks for the moderation Lucimay.
A Gunslinger did have a good point that I hadn't previously appreciated about Petty's charitable intentions. And I didn't mean to criticize you either onewyteduck.
It's ALL good...

yer welcome.

how was my Avatar imitation, Tankers?

Well, for a few moments there, I had thought it was Avatar......

Posted: Mon Sep 18, 2006 3:54 pm
by sgt.null
can anyone explain the love of Beyonce? i'd rather listen to Shatner warble any day of the week. I find most adult contemporary muzak just dreadfully dull...
Posted: Mon Sep 18, 2006 4:00 pm
by A Gunslinger
The Logical Song. Supertramp. For some reason I just can't take it.
Posted: Mon Sep 18, 2006 4:16 pm
by sgt.null
radical, liberal, fanatical, criminal...
Posted: Mon Sep 18, 2006 4:30 pm
by CovenantJr
Loremaster wrote:CovenantJr wrote:James Blunt. Anyone who's heard of him knows which song I mean.
Anything by James Blunt. He's boring.
The thing that gets me about Blunt is he isn't just blandly dull, he's
offensively dull.
Posted: Mon Sep 18, 2006 7:59 pm
by Usivius
did anyone mention: "Bad Medicine" by Bon Jovi?... yep, that's absolutely horrid.
My wife loved Bon Jovi, but thankfully she has never bought any of their albums... (whew)
"Lick It Up" .. by Kiss I think.... another horrid song.
Posted: Mon Sep 18, 2006 8:04 pm
by A Gunslinger
Those are terrible.
Posted: Mon Sep 18, 2006 8:24 pm
by dANdeLION
Oh, come on. JT is the KING of dull!