discussion from SRD GEN regarding possible spoiler on GI

[Usivius]

MOD EDIT: possible The Last Dark spoilers. Read at your own risk

I had just read this and was doing my "copy/paste" action when I saw your post.
Shocked me too.
I can only think that he, too, was being tongue-in-cheek, as he has plainly stated in the past that such questions are no longer relevant as it is a 'given' that the land is 'real'.
I think SRD is just stoking the fires...

[High Lord Tolkien]

I'll restrict myself to a short answer. Once you accept the notion that all of these characters find their genesis in Covenant's mind , the explanation is clear. Naturally they know all the words he knows.

(01/12/2011)

[Vraith]

An Interesting GI - what might it suggest?!

Hi Steve,

.. How come the people of the land have a command of vocabulary that's almost as good as yours? Cord Bhapa just used the word "guerdon" and I bet he doesn't have a copy of The Oxford English Dictionary. Or even one of your American Webster ones!...

I'll restrict myself to a short answer. Once you accept the notion that all of these characters find their genesis in Covenant's mind , the explanation is clear. Naturally they know all the words he knows.

(01/12/2011)

Now here, by the end of the Second Chronicles, I thought the Land was patently 'real' and external from Covenant ... What might this suggest for the Last Dark?!

I read that...and got a bit worried.
Off the top of my head, 3 possibilities, the first I hate:
It is a "just a dream" parallel/scenario in the end.
The second I'm not in love with, but could be OK depending how it works:
Genesis is an interesting word choice in this context, so perhaps it wasn't real, but in cooperation/relation/symbiosis...maybe even identity...with the Creator, it is now.
The third I most like:
The statement isn't as simple as it seems/is misdirection/only partial, and there are some surprises coming. [thematic ones, not just incidents that happen].

[rdhopeca]

I think he's said something like that in the past, maybe not worded quite that way, but that basically translation etc etc takes care of language so forth and so on...

He was probably just being brusque.

[aliantha]

If it's misdirection on SRD's part, it wouldn't be the first time.

[Seareach]

Hi everyone, I'm going to lock this thread. Please continue your discussion of this in kevinswatch.ihugny.com/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=20439