Kevin's Watch

First of all let me say that I stopped giving a crap about the Guardians of the Galaxy in the mid 80s and haven't read a book guest starring or featuring any version of the group since.

Now since Marvel announced that they were adapting the Guardians to a feature film in the same universe as the live action Avengers I have heard nothing but talk about Rocket Racoon and how it will be fantastic to see that character realized on the big screen.

IMHO there is no viable way to adapt that character without major loss of credibility. I don't care how cool the character is in the comics. (Which by the way is a matter of opinion). I've always enjoyed Howard the Duck but there isn't any way it was or could be possible to have a talking Duck fighting alongside Iron man or Captain America or Black Widow without it coming off like an acid trip and eliciting hearty guffaws.

And if anyone brings up the notion that Marvel was able to successfully integrate an animated character into the Avengers (Hulk) and make the argument that "if handled correctly" they'd have the same results with a talking Racoon...well... the very idea of it makes me a little nauseous.

I know it's been a while but the Guardians I remember were all at least humanoid and the stories they were involved in were indeed pretty cool and cosmic/galactic in nature so I'm not against the idea in principal but I just hope good sense doesn't get overridden by hardcore Guardians fans having a cow that their beloved Rocket Racoon was not included in the film, which I think would be the correct way to go.

Just my two bit opinion of course.

m - sorry, but Rocket Racoon is coolfighting along side Groot. i have no faith that the film will be any good, but the source material is excellent. i have that full run.

you can come over and read it.

Don't get me wrong. From a comic book standpoint I can see the appeal and I know that RR is cool. My point doesn't have anything to do with whether the character is interesting or exciting its whether it makes any sense at all to include him in a live action, semi-serious, big budget production. I'm saying...no.

As to dropping by one evening to read through the entire run of Guardians I'll have to consult my travel agent first.

tom - i have lots of stuff. you should stop by.

i do wish they had done a Starlord before this. if I were them I would tell the story that brought Starlord, Rocket Racoon, Groot, Mantis and Captain Universe together.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Annihilation:_Conquest

Hashi - there was a Doctor Strange movie made years ago.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dr._Strange_(1978_film)

Hashi Lebwohl wrote:Guardians of the Galaxy? My response when I first heard about this was "wtf?

That's the only sane response one can possibly have, considering the plethora of better characters to choose from. Groot? Rocket Racoon? Sounds like Saturday morning cartoon material to me.

Marvel has been doing so well with movies. Some fantastic, others merely good. Why would they want to go and screw their record with something that will so obviously screw their record?

sgt.null wrote:Hashi - there was a Doctor Strange movie made years ago.

Yes, I have seen it before. Although not bad, the character could do for a reboot and a plot with some updated themes. My advice for a Dr. Strange movie would be to introduce Strange, The Ancient One, Karl Mordo, and Clea but only hint at Dormammu (a faceless being we hear speaking to Mordo). Anyway...I digress.

There's a Dr Strange movie that appears to have been in development hell for the last 15 years or so, but may be in the works now...

Starlord, Starhawk, Groot, Mantis, Drax... the budget alone for make up and effects. my guess is they will dumb it down. and ruin it in the process.

hashi - Dr. Strange should make for an excellent film. use the Ditko art as a canvas.

and why not a Moon Knight film? a good Daredevil film?

Meh. Brunner's Strange was much better.

you know what movie needs to be made?

I wonder, would they film it in 3-d?

dANdeLION wrote:I wonder, would they film it in 3-d?

it would be the only 3D film i would watch...

As near as I can tell, I think they are doing a Guardians of the Galaxy Movie to introduce Thanos as a villain. Kinda like how Loki was introduced in the Thor movie before he was the main villain in The Avengers.

So why Guardians of the Galaxy? Because Silver Surfer is owned by someone else. And so is Fantastic Four. So the superheroes known by the public that would be in space and might encounter Thanos are off limits or following a different storyline (I'm thinking about Thor 2). So you get Guardians of the Galaxy since one of them is attached to Thanos (I forget which one).

Rocket Raccoon is the worst idea ever. Well, let me rephrase that: the current cinematic universe is not set up to have a talking raccoon as a protagonist. There is absolutely no precedent. It would appear from left field, it will rub the audiences the wrong way, there is no way they can 'do this right'.

You didn't need to rephrase it. People are going to hear the name 'Rocket Racoon" and immediately think he's a "Rocky Racoon" ripoff. Which is exactly what it is, isn't it? It won't be taken seriously, and if Thanos is thwarted in any way by RR, then he won't be taken seriously, either. Marvel should put Thanos in the next Iron Man movie, seeing as that's where he first appeared comic-wise.

Orlion wrote: So you get Guardians of the Galaxy since one of them is attached to Thanos (I forget which one).

Drax the Destroyer
Gamora

sgt.null wrote:Drax the Destroyer
Gamora

Wasn't Drax some sort of reanimated being programmed to fight Thanos?

Gamora was Thanos' favorite assassin, if I recall.

Arthur Douglas was a human whose family was attacked and killed by the supervillain Thanos. Needing a champion to combat Thanos, the being known as Kronos took Arthur's spirit and placed it in a powerful new body, and Drax the Destroyer was born. Drax's powers included enhanced strength and resilience, flight, and the ability to project energy blasts from his hands. The character often battled Thanos, and on occasion the superheroes Captain Marvel and Adam Warlock. He was also a member of the group known as the Infinity Watch.

Star-Lord recruits Drax for the new Guardians of the Galaxy. The Guardians are forced to ally themselves with a resurrected Thanos and travel into an alternate reality known as the "Cancerverse". While experiencing a bout of madness, Drax attacks Thanos and is killed. Drax later reappears with the Guardians on Earth without reference to his death.

kevinswatch.ihugny.com/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=22854

please check out the hero history of the Guardians I posted. they are a great team and I think if done as a serious movie, it could be great. I don't hold out that much hope though.