Oops - sorry forgot to login. That guest post is mine.

Finally saw this - the hype had built my expectations too high. Liked it up to the point where they arrived at the army base. After that it was became too predictable and cliched.

I'd rate it 3.5 out of 5.

Hi Roland. I'll take a shot at answering your question: WHY DID ARAGORN FALL OFF THE CLIFF AFTER THE SKIRMISH IN THE TWO TOWERS? PJ, Bowens, and Walsh used this to externally dramatize several things: 1) Gimili and Legolas' friendship between themselves and with Aragorn 2) Used it to provide an oppo...