StevieG wrote:Week 5 Summary:
Pies in the eight with a win over the Kangaroos! I thought they played very well for the first half - enough to encourage me! Cats have a big win over the Hawks - great game. They have Port next week, so could go further ahead at the top of the ladder after that game. Saints have pulled off a surprise win against the Bombers (so my wife's happy!). Carlton finally get a win on the board.
Pies a certainty for the 8 by seasons end imo; could still give the top 4 a shake, they've got too many good players - and a seemingly endless raft of youngsters coming through - not to.
Must admit I've only seen a couple of their games this season though StevieG - have Ben Reid and Paul Seedsman been playing? I think they were out both times I've watched the Pies - two very important players at any rate.
Very happy with the Cats win over Hawthorn, I really do hate the Hawks (my entire family barrack for them, too) and as usual it was an intense game.
St. Kilda have been really admirable imo, they'll do well and despite grim pre-season predictions they should finish somewhere around 9-12th
- which is kinda no-man's land -
but I think in recent times the benefits of tanking (high draft picks) has been overstated; teams that have been content to 'bottom out' or 'tank' for draft picks never seem to get it together; e.g. Melbourne, Carlton and to a lesser extent Richmond.
That kinda willful mediocrity ultimately leads to more of the same.
So St. Kilda are taking the high road imo; they may end up winning 'too many' games to qualify for the juicy draft picks, but what they will have gained - pride in their performance - will hold them in good stead for future years.
Good to see Essendon drop a game, not a fan of the Bombers.
Brisbane have been pretty woeful so far, Freo may not be quite as good as the experts were predicting, and the Kangaroos will continue to confound with Jekyl-and-Hyde performances ..
looking forward to Geelong's challenge this week against Port, who are an exciting young team with a heap of blossoming talent.